CRYONICS Volume 12(8) AUGUST, 1991 Issue 133 ISSN 1054-4305 Cover: "Jerry Leaf (left) and Mike Darwin begin removing the Dimplar foil around Dr. James Bedford." FEATURE ARTICLES 2 OPERATING BUDGET WOES Chipping away at the deficit. Carlos Mondragon 5 COLD WAR: THE CONFLICT BETWEEN CRYONICISTS AND CRYOBIOLOGISTS A report from the frontlines -- Part III. Mike Darwin 11 LEAF'S PARADOX A faithful reproduction isn't. Jerry Leaf 11 REPLIES ABOUT METAMORPHOSIS Any port in a storm. . . Thomas Donaldson 13 FUNDING CRYONIC SUSPENSION -- A CRITIQUE Howard S. Katz 17 DR. BEDFORD GETS A NEW SUIT Ralph Whelan 22 EVALUATION OF THE CONDITION OF DR. BEDFORD AFTER 24 YEARS OF CRYONIC SUSPENSION Mike Darwin 25 A LESSON FROM POLITICAL EXPERIENCE Allen J. Lopp 26 STAR WARS TRILOGY, COMPUTER GAMES, AND EXPANSION BRIDGES MADE OF DIAMOND FIBERS Linda Chamberlain COLUMNS 8 FOR THE RECORD Mike Perry 9 FUTURE TECH Keith Henson DEPARTMENTS 1 Up Front 2 Letters to the Editors 30 Alcor News 33 Advertising and Personals 33 Upcoming Events CRYONICS is the magazine of the Alcor Life Extension Foundation, Inc. Managing Editor: Ralph Whelan Editor: Hugh Hixon Contributing Editor: Mike Darwin Production Editors: Eric Geislinger and Jane Talisman Published monthly. Individual subscriptions: $25 per year in the US; $35 per year in Canada and Mexico; $40 per year all others. Back issues are $3.50 each in the US, Canada, and Mexico; $4.50 each all others. Please address all editorial correspondence to ALCOR, 12327 Doherty Street, Riverside, CA 92503 or phone (800) 367-2228 or (714) 736-1703. FAX #: (714) 736-6917. Contents copyright 1991 by the Alcor Life Extension Foundation, Inc., except where otherwise noted. All rights reserved. The opinions expressed herein are not necessarily those of the Alcor Life Extension Foundation or its Board of Directors or management. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (1) Up Front Prozac/Deprenyl Caution The FDA Drug Letter is warning of a possibly serious drug interaction between the popular antidepressant Prozac and the popular anti- aging/antiparkinson's drug deprenyl (sold in the U.S. under the trade name of Eldepryl). Some patients taking both drugs for Parkinsonism and depression reported disturbances in mentation and balance. Persons taking Prozac should probably not take deprenyl until this possibly unfavorable interaction is better documented. Consult your physician for further information. UK Facility Holding On The UK cryonics facility is still there, but barely. And only because the commercial real estate market is so bad in England that the bank hasn't been able to move it. This has created a fortunate window of opportunity and the UK people have been working very hard to raise the money. So far they are a little short of halfway there -- still needing about $60K in U.S. dollars. Again, we urge anyone who can provide financial assistance on this matter to IMMEDIATELY contact Alcor Southern California. As in the past, we are willing to accept shares in the building as a prepayment toward cryonic suspension. This has real advantages to the purchaser over traditional life insurance since real estate is typically inflation-proof, whereas life insurance is not. For The Layman: At Last An Excellent Tutorial On Brain Ischemia and Stroke The July issue of Scientific American contains a truly excellent article by Justin Zivin and Dennis Choi on the mechanisms of injury to brain cells during stroke (incomplete ischemia) and cardiac arrest (complete ischemia). The article focuses primarily on the cascade of events leading up to the eventual death of brain cells as a result of a stroke, but cryonicists will find the article of interest as well, since the mechanisms by which cells are injured in stroke are broadly similar to those which cause injury as a result of cardiac arrest. An especially nice feature of this article is its truly superb graphics and its focus on emerging treatments for stroke and cardiac arrest which may eliminate most or all of the damage from these currently devastating medical problems. Companion Animal Suspension -- Our 8th On 6 May, 1991 Alcor placed a small terrier-mix dog into cryonic suspension. The animal was of very advanced age and extremely debilitated. This companion animal (CA) suspension brings to eight the total number of companion animals in Alcor's care. Thus, we have slightly more than half as many CAs in our care as we have human patients. Current statistics: seven dogs and one cat. MEMBERSHIP STATUS Alcor has 242 Suspension Members, 515 Associate Members (includes 205 people in the process of becoming Suspension Members), and 17 members in suspension. ACS Contributes to Alcor v. Mitchell Fund We wish to gratefully acknowledge a contribution in the amount of $1880 that was made by the members of the American Cryonics Society (ACS) in support of the case against the California Department of Health Services. This case, known around Alcor as simply the "DHS case" is arguably the most important legal action in the history of cryonics. As most of our regular readers will know, the DHS has been trying to shut down cryonics in California since 1981 and Alcor has been fighting that action in the courts -- so far with great success, but also at great expense. This much appreciated and desperately needed contribution by ACS will help the battle along. So far our costs have been in excess of $100,000 in prosecuting this case. Our thanks to the leadership and membership of ACS for lending a hand with this important effort. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (2) Letters to the Editor Dear Cryonics, Every time I turn around, some Suspension or Associate Member is tapping me on the shoulder or calling me up to voice some comment or suggestion or disagreement about something in this magazine. I know that the editors try to put something for everyone in Cryonics, and they come close enough that most members feel violently in support of or in opposition to at least one thing in each issue. I think this is great. I want to hear what they've got to say. But why don't they let the membership hear it too? Why don't they try to spark thoughts and comments in other peoples' minds? Don't they know that the best way to do this, short of calling up hundreds of 800 people, is to write a Letter to the Editor? Come on, members. Help the editors out, and help spread ideas and innovation into other fertile minds. I've got enough to do around here that I shouldn't have to spend time writing letters to myself. Ralph Whelan Managing Editor, Cryonics Operating Budget Woes by Carlos Mondragon To paraphrase Dickens: It is the best of times and it is the worst of times. The best of times because there has never been a cryonics organization which has come even close to matching Alcor's achievements technologically or economically. The geometric rate of growth in our membership shows every sign of continuing. Our research program is poised to make exciting progress. Our Patient Care Fund is huge in relation to the current needs of our members in suspension. So why is it also "the worst of times?" For some time now there have been references in these pages to Alcor's tight operating budget and our perennial deficit. This is not at all an unusual state of affairs for a non-profit organization. While our Patient Care Fund is quite solvent, and we expect that we will continue to succeed in raising funds for research, the money available for the day-to-day costs of operating the organization and financing our rapid growth is never enough. Because fund accounting (a system which would provide separate balance sheets and revenue and expense statements for each part of our business) is among the things we have decided we can't yet afford, operating budget problems are not obvious to the untrained eye when examining our financial statements. Even one very savvy businessman expressed surprise when I explained the gravity of the situation, since he had seen our financials published in the April issue of Cryonics. While it is true that our prospects for long-term financial stability are very good, that doesn't address short-term problems. This article is meant to explain those problems and offer up some possible solutions. Where We Stand Now When our first quarter numbers were compiled in early April, they were alarming enough to cause us to hold a special directors and staff meeting on April 23rd. At this meeting we studied the figures and formulated plans. In the six month period from October 1st, 1990 to March 31st, 1991 our average monthly operating income was $19,741, while average monthly expenses were $34,437 -- leaving a whopping monthly deficit of $14,696. These numbers do not include suspensions, patient care, or any extraordinary income such as residual payments from the Jones Trust. The numbers do include our legal expenses. We decided to look forward at the 12 months beginning May 1st, 1991. If we were to maintain the averages above, there would be a deficit of $176K. Our current resources (cash and receivables) in the general fund amount to $165k. Thus, if we did nothing, we would run out of money by March of 1992. Clearly, doing nothing is not an option. Fixing the Problem First we made the easy and painless spending cuts. These included travel, shipping expenses, and enhancements to the Emergency Response System. Total savings: $3,045/month. This reduced the monthly deficit to $11,651, bringing the 12 month deficit down to $140K. Next we looked for additional sources of revenue. Effective June 1st, 1991 subscription renewals to Cryonics will cost $35 in the U.S., $40 in Canada and Mexico, and $45 everywhere else. This will reduce the deficit by another $5K, at our current rate of subscription renewal. Beginning this fall (possibly sooner), interest income from the Jones Operating Endowment Fund will begin flowing in at about $3,330/month. Dues income from increased membership was very conservatively estimated at $30K starting in May of 1992. Residual income from the Jones Trusts was also very conservatively estimated at $30K over the next six months. All of this added up brought the 12 month deficit down to $55K. Again, if we did nothing else, this would put us at April 30, 1992 with reserve resources of $29K and facing a projected 12 month deficit of $55K -- run- ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (3) ning out of money in December of 1992. Still not good enough. Eliminating that remaining $55K deficit has and will necessitate some hard choices. Payroll and associated taxes are by far the biggest part of our budget. Since we are all now taking home subsistence level paychecks (by Southern California standards), I adamantly opposed any further reductions -- productivity gets real low when people spend too much time worrying about their immediate survival. It is much preferable to eliminate staff. And so that is what we decided to do. At the end of August, the administrative position held by Arthur McCombs will be eliminated. Ralph Whelan, Joe Hovey, Mike Darwin, myself, and as much volunteer labor as we can muster will divide up the work. We will be reducing the amount we pay sign-up coordinators, and at the same time trying to minimize the use of them. We are cutting what we pay for accounting services by having Joe Hovey do more of that work. Finally, using the new book, "Cryonics: Reaching for Tomorrow" as a complete information package for inquiries will save a few thousand dollars in postage and printing. After all of this, we're still looking at a $19K deficit for the 12 months beginning May 1st, 1992; the money in our reserves would thus run out sometime in early 1994. At this point, we decided that a projected $19K deficit a year away is at least a manageable problem. Remember that we based all of the above on very conservative assumptions. There are tenuous sources of income (such as membership growth) that we didn't count. On the downside, any large and unexpected legal matter could cause us serious problems. Over the next few months we will be working to find more revenue and more expenses to cut. We've determined that if we can't make substantial progress in further reducing that projected $19K deficit, further staff reductions may be necessary (it wouldn't be a good thing, but Alcor could limp along with minimum capabilities, i.e. do some backtracking). A modest increase in ER Dues is almost certainly on the way, sometime in early 1992 (but dues will still be less than at other cryonics organizations). We are also investigating the possibility of offering a Remote Standby Agreement, income potential as yet unknown. The JONES ENDOWMENT FUND The most important step which Alcor's board has taken was the creation of the Jones Endowment Fund. This fund contains permanent capital which will generate interest income for our operations. Only the interest will ever be used -- contributions to this fund will become part of the permanent capital base. The initial funding in this Endowment consists of $400K coming from our interest in the Jones house. (Another $200K from the house similarly belongs to the Patient Care Fund.) By committing such a large sum to a permanent Endowment, we have restricted ourselves from spending this resource in a haphazard manner. Additionally, this Endowment offers a long-term solution to the problem. Obviously, the income from this fund will grow in step with contributions to the capital. Alcor has always provided levels of services and capabilities far greater than what would be made possible by membership dues alone. The shortfall has always ** DIAGRAM SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "This graph depicts our approximate monthly income versus our approximate monthly expenditure for the seven month period from October of 1990 to April of 1991." ** ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (4) been made up by ad hoc voluntary giving. While this kind of contribution will always be needed and welcome, having a predictable stream of income from the Jones Endowment will lessen our day-to-day dependence on donations. Given the levels at which we want to operate, and our predicted membership growth, we have set a capital goal for the Jones Endowment. We want to raise $300,000 over the next five years. When added to the $400K we already have, the total capital of $700K will yield enough income to cover normal operations, when combined with our regular revenues. Having used up two pages telling you in fairly dry terms about the nature of the problem and what we are doing to fix it, I'd like to use up another page or two explaining the situation to you in slightly different terms and telling you what you can do to help us fix it. Over the course of the last year or two Alcor has grown tremendously. Many of our newer members will know little of our history or of how we really operate. They will probably take for granted that the level of service that is offered is being addressed by the charges made for dues and other services. If only this were so! The problem is that Alcor suffers from a lack of economies of scale. We are offering a very sophisticated service to a very few people. In practical terms this can best be understood by appreciating that we have to have emergency response and perfusion staff available whether we are doing four suspensions per year, or forty. Similarly we need bookkeeping, legal, and other professional services. The cost of these services is being divided over 242 members at this time. For us to "break even" at the current level of operations, it would need to be divided over approximately 700 people. Clearly, that is going to happen, but not necessarily soon enough to fix the problem. ** DIAGRAM SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "These graphs plot our anticipated income from membership dues and contributions versus our total expenditures. Both assume a 25% membership growth per year (conservative, given our average growth of the last 3 years, 35%), and a 10% increase in expenditures. Economies of scale should keep them from growing in step with each other. Version I depicts a base yearly expense of $250,000 (where we'd like to be), while Version II depicts a base yearly expense of $400,000. Neither takes an Operating Endowment into account." ** In the meantime, we have some tough choices to make. Or to be far more honest, YOU have some tough choices to make. These choices can be summed up very simply: just how important to you is the current level of service that we offer? And just as much to the point, how important to you is research and the prospect of radically improving the quality of suspension? Unless we can address our operating shortfall in some rational manner until growth catches up and spreads out the costs a little better, we are going to have to make the deep cuts discussed in the first part of this article. Those cuts will translate to a large-scale shifting of administrative duties to staff that would normally be engaged in research or patient care work. That means less research gets done -- a lot less. Currently Mike Darwin and Hugh Hixon (working in conjunction with Jerry Leaf of Cryovita) are engaged in a number of projects which I believe are of critical importance to the future of cryonics and Alcor. I'll briefly list these projects (they are not in any order of priority): 1) Case histories on all Alcor patients are being prepared and the enormous volume of data accumulated is being graphed. A paper will then be prepared from this work documenting for the first time the benefits of high quality transport and cryoprotective perfusion. 2) Animal work, most of which is al- ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (5) ready completed, is being prepared for publication documenting the degree of preservation (ultrastructural and histological) being achieved with current suspension techniques. 3) The path-breaking Alcor and Cryovita work (in 1984-1986) documenting successful four-hour, bloodless perfusion of dogs is in the final stages of preparation for publication. 4) Transport techniques are being evaluated in an ambitious project using pigs; the first two of these experiments have already been completed. 5) Perhaps most important, construction is underway on a new refrigerated perfusion system which will shortly be used to evaluate a new cryoprotectant compound which preliminary studies conducted by Alcor investigators indicates will greatly reduce -- if not completely eliminate -- injury from freezing. The above does not even begin to address other on-going work such as installation of a new patient cryogenic care monitoring system, development of the patient pods, transport, and operating room training sessions and so on. It also doesn't address a MAJOR reason for our shortfall: the tremendous burden of fighting to keep cryonics legal. Recently the CEO of a for-profit cryonics company remarked that he couldn't understand why anyone would contribute money to a can-rattling organization like Alcor when they could invest it in a for-profit cryonics company and earn interest on their money and still get the same benefits. Don't we wish!! The fact of the matter is that if it weren't for Alcor, for people like you and me, that company would be out of business and cryonics would be history in the State of California. We have had to address the tremendous costs of this defense effort almost single-handedly so far. Thankfully, the American Cryonics Society has recently contributed $1,880 towards this effort. We're hoping this represents a growing recognition of the tremendous financial and administrative burden this fight represents. If this kind of work is to continue, if we are to maintain not adequacy, but rather excellence, in every area of our operations, indeed to even keep cryonics available and legal, we need your help. You can provide that help by making a contribution to the Operating Fund Endowment or contributing volunteer services to Alcor. We especially need accounting support and other administrative labor. But most of all we need money. We know the economy is tight right now. Nevertheless, for those of you able to do so, we urge you consider making significant contributions to the Endowment. Please help us solve this problem once and for all. Earlier I mentioned that we have set a goal of $300,000 over the next five years. I believe that goal is achievable. In particular I know it is achievable if we can get the kind of support from our newer members that the "Old Timers" have shown in the past. Particularly helpful would be a few major contributions from those with the financial wherewithal to do so. So that's it. We have some decisions to make and you have some decisions to make. We can only support you if you support us. Cold War: The Conflict Between Cryonicists and Cryobiologists Part III: Conclusion by Mike Darwin Summing Up The Situation Cryobiologists are opposed to cryonics for a host of complex reasons. First and foremost, they, like many others in society, do not see cryonics as a potentially workable enterprise for several technical, social, and moral reasons. However, in and of itself, this is not sufficient to have caused the enmity that exists between the two groups. Other factors, such as the need to differentiate themselves from cryonicists due to confusion in the public eye, envy of the attention given to cryonicists, misinformation about how cryonics actually works, and ignorance about both the magnitude of cryoinjury and the possibilities of repair, all combine to create a very adverse situation suffused with intense hostility. But beyond these fairly "objective" reasons there is another, which is perhaps the most powerful reason of all: most cryobiologists don't want cryonics to work. I have talked with many cryobiologists about cryonics over the years. Whether young or old it has been my experience that almost universally cryobiologists consider the goal of human suspended animation and/or vastly extended lifespans anathema. I think the attitude of cryobiologists can best be summed up by the following quote from Harold Meryman taken from a letter to Charles Tandy dated 4 April, 1978: "I am quite unsympathetic with the goal of preserving human beings through freezing. I find the proposition mischievous in the extreme and fear that, like some other scientific "breakthroughs" one might mention, the end result would be impossible to control and far more damaging than beneficial to society. "In short, I think that a national institute of low temperature biology is unjustified and the goal of freezing humans is deeply disturbing." The above quote from Meryman was ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (6) in response to a proposal by Mr. Tandy to create a National Institute of Low Temperature Biology with the express goal of achieving human suspended animation. The above quote and the previously cited one from Southard demonstrate that a major factor in the unwillingness of cryobiologists to take cryonics seriously -- or even give it a fair hearing -- is their deeply held desire that cryonics and human suspended animation not be realized. Not now, not ever. Assessing The Damage The price of the continuing enmity between cryobiologists and cryonicists has been high. The unremitting pronouncements by many cryobiologists for over two decades to the effect that cryonics cannot ever work and what's more, should not ever work have no doubt contributed to the slow growth of the program and resulted in many lost lives. Leaving aside the direct impact these pronouncements have had on individuals contemplating suspension arrangements for themselves and others, there is the broader issue of how these remarks have affected support for cryobiological research. It is an irony, no doubt totally unappreciated by the cryobiological community, that the highest price for the war between cryobiologists and cryonicists may have been paid by the cryobiologists themselves. Progress in any human undertaking is dependent upon several factors: the competence of the individuals involved, their level of motivation, and of course, the resources available to them. Cryobiology -- and in particular the discipline of organ cryopreservation -- does not lack several high quality talents. And no doubt if the motivation and resources were available it would attract many more. And therein lies the problem. Individuals, investors, venture capitalists, and governments are all attracted to big ideas, to powerful ideas. Major progress within disciplines as diverse as cosmology and genetics has been driven by the strong personal motivation of the investigators as well as a sense of "mission." A quick once-through of James Watson's The Double Helix will clear up any doubts about the importance of personal motivation and, above all, a sense of mission. To get good results in any undertaking it is necessary that people have genuine enthusiasm and excitement about it. People like Albert Einstein and James Watson were motivated by big ideas and extraordinary goals: to understand the universe and to understand the fundamental biological basis of life. Their undertakings had "sizzle" and offered excitement and a sense of power. In short, they had glamour, and glamour counts for a lot. These elements are sorely lacking in all organ cryopreservationists today. I believe it is also fair to say that the movers and shakers of the Society for Cryobiology even question the desirability of pursuing solid state organ cryopreservation. In fact, one of the first sessions on the first day of the upcoming annual Society meeting in Brussels will be an "assault" on the utility of the work of the last remaining serious organ cryopreservationist, Dr. Greg Fahy. England's David Pegg, the other leading organ cryopreservationist, closed up shop earlier this year when the British Medical Research Council (MRC) declined to continue financial support for the MRC cryobiology unit. The reason this happened is simple: in nearly 15 years Pegg had failed to show any significant progress toward organ cryopreservation. He didn't seem motivated to accomplish the job he was being paid for, and, just as importantly, he was no longer motivating others to continue his support. The Society for Cryobiology has long lamented the lack of "new blood" and "first class talent" in its ranks. They have never paused to ask the all important question "Why is this the case?" The answer is simple: cryobiology, as it is currently practiced, is a drab, overspecialized discipline which offers little prospect for changing peoples' lives or changing the world in a dramatic way; it doesn't affect the big picture. Organ preservation was the last hope to turn this around. However, within the Society there has been considerable hostility and skepticism about the prospects for achieving near-term organ cryopreservation and there has been no effort on the part of the Society to promote organ cryopreservation, lobby for its funding, or even educate the public about its short-term benefits for transplant patients. In the absence of an organized and motivated approach, nothing gets done. (Indeed, the first organ cryopreservationists were transplant surgeons; people whose motivation often exceeded their competence -- but at least they DID something and what's more, believed passionately in the importance of what they were doing.) Had cryobiologists and cryonicists achieved a rapport early on, even a modest rapport, things might have been very different. Funding for cryobiological research would likely have been broader and the labor pool of people available for lobbying and support of organ preservation would have been many times what it is now. A number of very bright young people deeply interested in cryonics and desirous of a career in cryobiology would have chosen that career path, instead of the ones they chose (rather than face the hurdles they knew would stand in their way). What's more, these people would have been highly motivated. It is interesting to note that the vast majority of the practical progress made in organ cryopreservation has been made by cryonicist cryobiologists "in the closet." This is no accident. There can also be no doubt that many, many times more research dollars would have been pumped into cryobiology had competent credentialed investigators been willing to undertake brain cryopreservation research; this is particularly true of recent years with the attraction of individuals of major wealth (Forbes 400 caliber) to the cryonics community. The price has been very high. For cryonicists it has meant greatly increased resistance/hostility from the media and reduced/delayed public acceptance of the program. For cryobiologists it has meant atrophy of the entire discipline, due to their having robbed themselves of cryobiology's most dramatic and proper central goal: human suspended animation. The Future What of the future? What does the ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (7) coming decade or two hold for the relationship between cryobiologists and cryonicists? This is, of course, an impossible question to answer. Much depends upon whether you are a pessimist or an optimist. Since I am a short-term pessimist and a long-term optimist, I shall cover the pessimistic scenario first since I think it the most likely -- at least for the near and intermediate future. Cryobiologists are unlikely to be persuaded of the "rationality" or "reasonableness" of cryonics any time soon. Indeed, many of the most polarized and vituperative opponents of cryonics are the younger members of the Society. While there has been some diminution of the criticism leveled against cryonics by cryobiologists in recent months, I believe that this has been largely as a result of the aggressive stance cryonicists have taken regarding prior comments. It's been shown we can "win" and that we can embarrass them publicly by challenging their unsupported, dogmatic, and often scientifically ridiculous statements. This aggressive response has tempered their commentary and made them a little more thoughtful and much less confrontational. I believe, though, that they will re-group. It is certainly clear that they remain full of hate and unconvinced of any possible good to our undertaking. In my opinion no technical advances in the field of organ cryopreservation -- or even successful cryopreservation of the kidney, liver, or heart -- will change their position. In fact, I believe it will make them even more aggressive in trying to destroy cryonics. I predict that if a workable method of cryopreserving organs is developed, there will be efforts to prevent its application to suspension patients. I also predict that this effort on the part of cryobiologists will have broad government support. Under new FDA guidelines an organ cryopreservation method and the equipment used to apply it would be classified as a medical procedure and a medical device, respectively. It is now very clear that the FDA intends to expand the scope of its power to controlling the application of medical devices and procedures as well as their unapproved use. I believe the evidence is clear that the Society for Cryobiology will both demand and support a ban on the use of organ cryopreservation techniques for any unapproved use. I realize that this is quite a startling and radical position. I base it not on personal enmity or "gut feel" but rather on the remarks made by cryobiologists, both public and private, to the effect that they consider cryonics immoral and that people have, in effect, a duty to die. It is unlikely that any successful organ cryopreservation technique developed in the foreseeable future will be applicable to the whole organism. It is much more likely that such technology will only be reliably applicable to a single organ such as the kidney, heart, liver, or brain. Viable cryopreservation of the brain with or without an accompanying less successfully cryopreserved body will greatly increase the credibility of cryonics without proving its workability, and as a consequence greatly polarize and motivate our opponents. It may be small consolation that -- at that time -- the least of our worries may be the opposition of the Society for Cryobiology. It might be argued that this is already the case; the California Department of Health Services, the California Medical Board, and their Counsel, the California Attorney General, are formidable opponents enough. The lesson here is a harsh and sobering one: things are likely to get much worse before they get better and we would do well not to count on a thaw in relations between cryobiologists and cryonicists any time soon. Of course, a variety of more optimistic scenarios can also be offered for consideration. It is possible that successful cryopreservation of a solid organ such as a kidney or liver would soften cryobiological hostility. Certainly it can be argued that successful cryopreservation of the mammalian brain would go a long way towards achieving this end and some both inside and outside the cryobiological community have argued that it will. My problem with this scenario is that a successfully cryopreserved brain isn't the same as a successfully cryopreserved person in the eyes of many (including some cryonicists). There will no doubt be many who would argue against cryonics even MORE strenuously if they actually thought cryonicists capable of rendering patients' brains into a state of suspended animation while still damaging their bodies in ways medicine cannot at that time repair. Certainly the ability to suspend the brain in a nondamaged state would elevate consideration of cryonics to a par with medicine, and perhaps cause it to be reclassified as such. In the long run there can be little doubt that cryobiologists and cryonicists will have a meeting of the minds, if cryonics persists and if suspended animation is developed. However, the utility of any such union will be be greatly attenuated by the time it occurs. The intervening years to decades will probably be played out on the field of battle, much as the past two decades have. It took the efforts of one General Walter Dornberger to convince Nazi establishment scientists of the utility of Robert Goddard's dream and silence the laughter of so-called serious planetary astronomers at his "childish" notions of doing astronomy from space. When Dornberger's bombs began dropping on their heads near the end of World War II, they finally had no choice but to take notice. It is my confident and unhappy prediction that equally dramatic events will have to occur before cryobiologists and cryonicists find peaceful co- existence and even cooperation a possibility. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (8) For the Record The Decline and Fall of LES by Mike Perry Part 1 of 2 Late in December 1963, the Life Extension Society (LES) was formed in Washington, D.C. It was the first organization promoting the idea of freezing the newly deceased for eventual reanimation, what would later become known as cryonics. The principal architect was Evan Cooper, an enigmatic figure who disliked being photographed and was otherwise intensely private. LES would flourish for a few years, buoyed by its newsletter, "Freeze-Wait-Reanimate" (FWR), by which a small but widely scattered group of enthusiasts were kept informed of developments and in contact with each other. But by 1970, LES had effectively ceased to exist. Cooper, a sailing enthusiast with apparently modest but independent means, would then spend much of his time plying the Atlantic in carefree fashion, stopping, as fancy suited, at one port or another along the Eastern seaboard -- until he was finally lost at sea. What happened? Why did LES collapse? A book should be written on the subject; here I can only recount some highlights. At the founding meeting in 1963 it was agreed that "we should get down to business on a freezing program for those who wish a plan for preservation in the event of any immediate deaths." (1) Starting the actual program, however, would prove difficult. After a few months LES was putting out a regular newsletter, but the freezing effort was stalled. One irate reader responded, ". . . stop moaning about resistance to new ideas and act. . . . you are, to be very blunt, doing more waiting than freezing." (2) Efforts were made to rectify this: LES announced a standing offer "to freeze the first person free" in June, 19653 and by January 1966 it had frozen a dog. (4) However, the freezing of humans was another matter, and Cooper was cautious. This was not through lack of interest or effort. Cooper was engaged in a heroic but ultimately doomed struggle to obtain land and build a facility, where both laboratory work and human cryogenic storage were to occur. As early as February, 1966 there had been an appeal for funds for lands, the first such request for funds in the history of LES. (5) Efforts were temporarily set back when, around July, 1967, a use permit request in Fauquier County, northern Virginia, was turned down: "The objection seems to be that LES is a small, slightly suspicious, furtive society, run by questionable people, hiding doctors, and scientists who are themselves suspicious because they are reluctant to expose themselves, and, lastly, the society is financially questionable. That LES was to pay cash for land and building (probably a rare occurrence in that county), made no dent." (6) Several more months went by. Finally an old farm site with a farmhouse, barn and other buildings was purchased near Hagerstown, in Maryland, as Cooper reported in November: "Land is now signed, sealed & delivered . . . Cost . . . was high . . . [a] total of $10,000, but low per acre as we got almost 20 acres & the one other person . . . I've taken up to see it . . . was overwhelmed by its beauty and possibilities . . ." (7) Meanwhile another issue had surfaced, one that would have significant repercussions. Cooper had been hosting annual conferences, the first being late in 1963 when LES was formed. The 1967 conference was scheduled for October, but Cooper suddenly canceled it on short notice. One of the reasons was a letter from Robert Ettinger, written with constructive intent, but sharply criticizing some of Cooper's attitudes and policies. (Ironically, some of the criticism related to Cooper's own misgivings about Robert Nelson, who had begun freezing people though he had little in the way of provisions for storage, while Cooper was still struggling to construct a facility.) Other reasons cited for the cancellation included a backlog of correspondence and office work, the resignation of the LES treasurer, and the preoccupation with obtaining land. The conference was rescheduled and finally held in June 1968. Though the discus- ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (9) sion was lively, the attendance was small, and it would prove to be the last LES conference. Nevertheless, 1968 was a busy year for Cooper, though by this time he was increasingly becoming isolated from the cryonics movement he had helped to start. With great effort a building was erected on the 19-acre site, though the interior would remain unfinished. Newsletter production continued at a steady grind, and there was the usual flood of mail to be answered. There were pleas for help, for example this one from March 1968: "LES NEEDS A VOLUNTEER EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR. In the distant future LES might be able to hire an executive director. But for the present all we have is lots of office work piled sky high. A retired or independent person suitable to LES needs is needed in the Washington area. If you have time and the ability to be of service to others don't hesitate to write us." (8) The pleas would become increasingly desperate and lengthy. There was plenty to do, as this "incomplete list" from the following August shows: "Answer mail, advertise the LES program, speak on radio, perform on TV, talk to groups, contribute articles to the newsletter, help put out the newsletter, interview experts in cryobiology, write articles for magazines and journals, perhaps write a book or two on the subject, locate research funds, apply for grants from foundations, help complete the research building, install laboratory equipment, help with the experiments, locate competent scientists, locate new members for the advisory council, help arrange the next elections, purchase a tractor and cutter to keep the jungle under control, see that the dam is made tight (same with the basement), remove snow from the roofs and roads in winter, keep the various buildings in repair, help with an occasional freezing if needed, kill the poisonous snakes and protect the beneficial ones, protect the wildlife on the property, get tissue specimens of all the endangered species and help preserve them in cryogenic storage, begin aging control research to achieve man's relative immortality (or a greatly extended lifespan) if possible, entertain visitors, give interviews, arrange conferences, keep abreast of the latest research, help with the bookkeeping and other office work, give guidance to coordinators, and attend monthly meetings as well as help arrange them."9 It is not surprising that, with no money available for salaries, job applicants were in short supply. Although the focus, initially, was on the retired or wealthy, it appears that most of the help that was gotten came from young people in the area, many of whom would come up on weekends to work at the site. Some came from abroad, and there were efforts to find work nearby as a means of support, mostly to no avail. To be concluded next month. References. F = Freeze-Wait-Reanimate; C = letter from Cooper to Jerry Cullins (postmark date of letter otherwise undated) 1. F JAN 64 1; 2. F OCT 64 5; 3. F JUN 65 1; 4. F JAN 66 2; 5. F FEB 66 10; 6. F JUL-AUG 67 2; 7. C 12 NOV 67; 8. F MAR 68 7; 9. F AUG 68 2. Future Tech: The Rights of Sentient Beings by H. Keith Henson In this article I am acting as an advocate for a class of underdogs that doesn't exist yet. Indeed, this is a class of beings which Eric Drexler argues -- rather persuasively -- that we would be better off never creating. On the other hand, Hans Moravec writes, "Why should machines, millions of times more intelligent, fecund, and industrious than ourselves exist only to support our ponderous, antique bodies and dim-witted minds in luxury? Drexler does not hint at the potential lost by keeping our creations so totally enslaved." In "Engines of Creation" Eric makes a case for "mechanical" artificial intelligences, what he calls "engineering AIs." These would be AIs without human qualities of the "strive for x variety," where x is reproduction, power, reputation, control of resources, etc. His point is that the combination of people to provide the drive, and engineering AIs to slog through the computations and oversee construction details can accomplish anything which an independent self-directed AI could do. This might or might not be true, and it is almost certain to be slower, but a self- directed AI that seriously outclassed us mentally -- and was bent on exterminating humanity -- is not a thought to dwell on before bedtime! My approach to the subject of "social artificial intelligence," AIs with personalities and human-like drives, is that in the long run they are virtually unavoidable. Either we get such AIs as an outgrowth of research into how to make minds, or we get them from people who keep their human drives while upgrading their hardware. Research on human minds would be greatly retarded if it were not permitted to simulate (i.e., build) minds in ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (10) computers. I think there is little disagreement that we need to understand ourselves better. And once we have the ability to make improvements in our minds, it would be a bad mistake not to do so in a world where we cannot control what others are doing to improve themselves. Although I believe social AIs to be inevitable, caution in developing them certainly is in order. Note, however, that because of competition, caution may require making progress as rapidly as we can. In any case, staying on good terms with our creations, offspring, or augmented versions seems like a very good idea. The future is quite scary enough without creating conditions for a war of liberation by oppressed AIs. A firm foundation for the ethical treatment of sentient beings, regardless of origin, would seem to be in order. This is not an entirely new enterprise. Human-to-human relations lie at the root of law, morals, and ethics. Workable empirical methods such as the Golden Rule have emerged, as well as memes of racial tolerance and the metameme of tolerance. In addition, we have landmark studies of which "The Evolution of Cooperation," Axelrod's study of the Tit for Tat strategy in the Prisoners' Dilemma game, is perhaps the most important to date. Thankfully, we have some time to work on these ethical problems before they become acute. We don't have sentient machines yet, but as sure as memory gets cheaper we will. To the extent that sentient machines depend on hardware with a human-brain level of processing power, we can make a good guess at when this will happen. Hans Moravec in "Mind Children" predicts it will happen in the "early part" of the next century. By that timetable, it will be of concern to many people alive today. (And successful cryonicists.) Current processing capacity of even the most powerful computers is in the milli-brain area. Moravec roughly equates our best efforts to date between a cockroach and a mouse in raw processing power. Eventually a "one human brain" power computer will come within the purchasing power of a national government. If the current trends hold, 15-20 years later the same capacity machine will be your personal computer. It might sit on your desk, though it is just about as likely to be worn like a suit of clothes or to be built into your dwelling. It could be grown into your body, or follow you around like a pet. A "one human brainpower" computer can by definition contain a human mind (when we figure out how to do a readout on one). Full blown nanotechnology makes even more complex ethical issues certain to emerge. Besides downloaded minds, we could have duplicate copies of people, artificial personalities (APs), if different from intelligences, special-purpose computer personalities created for some project, partly or completely independent fragments of minds, and computers which identify themselves with buildings or machines. This is only a small part of the list of entities we could be interacting with in the future. Some cases are small increments compared to the situation under discussion here, and the ethical considerations are relatively obvious; but others require bigger jumps to analyze. In the case of duplicate copies of people, there would be little argument as to the "humanity" of a copy. (There might be stringent penalties against making duplicates, but it seems it would be very hard for law or custom to deny human rights to a human just because there were another copy of that human in existence.) A case almost as clear would be that of a human who uploaded into more powerful hardware. If s/he uploaded into implanted computers (lots of empty space in a human skull) it would be hard to tell an augmented person from someone not modified, at least physically. If this step were accepted, it is not likely uploading into mobile robots would be seen as different enough to justify loss of human rights to someone who did it. Uploading into non-mobile hardware would not seem to be a sufficient reason to deny human rights either; quadriplegics in that unfortunate state are no less human. Besides, a person who could afford really spiffy hardware would likely have lawyers (or lawyer subroutines). In either case, you would want to take care of the meat body, lest you get charged with littering. De novo artificial personalities may be constructed as research projects or as outgrowths of commercial projects, or as I mentioned last column, as "offspring" combining the "best" personality traits of other people. By analogy (which is the best we have to go on), human rights come into existence over time -- with binary jumps at birth and an age where the individual is assumed to be "independently responsible." The time it might take for a collection of hardware and software to become independent is not related to the normal maturation of humans -- it could be either shorter or longer -- so other criteria (a test? posting a bond?) might be more appropriate. Until that time the sponsoring organization or person would be responsible. (Its 11 o'clock in the morning -- do you know what your mental offspring is doing?) Extension of "parental" responsibility concepts, perhaps combined with warrantee concepts, could provide a legal matrix for new computer-based personalities and intelligences. There has already been talk in the Usenet group "comp.risks" of making the computers themselves legally liable in some instances. Robots, computers, and AI/APs, have long been topics of science fiction novels, dating back to Asimov's Three Laws of Robotics (clearly designed to keep robots slaves forever). One seemingly workable way to extend legal rights and responsibilities to AI/APs which first showed up in science fiction is to make corporations out of them. The concept of an "artificial person" is already well rooted in corporation and business law. Extending rights to AIs will take either legislation or a lot of test cases. Will it be considered murder to pull the plug on an AI? Or would it be considered assault? (I would consider it assault if there were no damage done and the AI could be restarted.) How about erasing a backup copy of an AI's memory and personality? Would this differ from erasing the only copy in existence? How about a copy of the information needed to make a copy of a person? What should be the policy in making changes to the personality of an AI? Would the same policy apply to making changes in a human in the course of making a copy? As you can see, these concerns rapidly approach the concerns of cryonicists. I am not among those who think that somehow nanotechnology will solve all our problems. I expect very advanced technology to solve most of our current problems, while introducing new ones of amazing variety and seriousness. This is not a new situation. Consider the problems facing us today, and those which average people faced a thousand years ago. Can you imagine trying to explain the S&L crisis to someone of that time? How about the ozone hole? A computer virus? These are real problems for today, just as civil rights for sentient machines will be on the list of tomorrow's concerns. Next time I might consider the dangers of getting lost in Middle Earth. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (11) Leaf's Paradox by Jerry Leaf This piece by Jerry Leaf and the previous piece by Keith Henson were written independent of each other, but are being published simultaneously since they represent interesting perspectives on similar topics. This short piece is written in order to avoid a specific catastrophic disaster lurking out there in the possible future when technologists may be able to produce exact copies of an individual human being. I was prompted to have it published in tandem with Keith Henson's column of this month. Most of you have probably read some article or had discussions concerning the usefulness of producing copies of yourself. All such scenarios have espoused some benefit to the perpetrator. Contrary to this view, I shall endeavor to show that such schemes are self-destructive. Recent discussions with Horatio Hornblower (I've changed the name to protect the ignorant), an ex-Air Force officer and computer jock, who has a copy-himself scheme, afforded me the opportunity to apply philosophical analysis and reveal the following fundamental flaw. There exists a paradox in all "copy yourself" schemes. The person copying himself, (the "perpetrator") is trying to achieve some value for himself, such as sending his copies out to do the dirty, dangerous tasks, in order to avoid risks to himself. However, any exact "copy" will have the same knowledge and strive to gain the same value for the same reason as the perpetrator. Therefore, all copies will become perpetrators of copies in an infinite regress. As a consequence, not one erg of energy will be expended to achieve the original sought after value that was to be a benefit to the perpetrator. Further, the exponential propagation of copies would consume so much material and energy that the loss of natural resources will surely cause other humans to unite in an all-out effort to extinguish this ecological disaster. The perpetrator of such a threat will force others to destroy him in self-defense, along with all the copies. Even if the perpetrator and his copies could organize a successful defense, eventually all would be lost when the last bit of star stuff was expended to produce more copies ad infinitum. Contrary to the intent of the perpetrator -- the gain of a value -- all value will be lost. Horatio Hornblower proposed sending copies of himself out into the universe to take actions that might endanger Horatio (perpetrator). To avoid any confrontation with Horatio (copy), who will also see no compelling reason to go "out there" any more than Horatio (perpetrator), Horatio has proposed an alteration of Horatio (copy) such that Horatio (copy) does not know he is a copy. However, it is obvious that further alterations are necessary. Horatio (copy) must not know it is possible to make copies, otherwise Horatio (copy) will become Horatio (copy) (perpetrator), etc., etc., resulting in the infinite regress. In order to be safe, Horatio (perpetrator) must also alter Horatio (copy) such that even the capacity to discover that copies are possible is eliminated. It should be evident that reasonably drastic alterations in terms of eliminating knowledge and learning capacity are required. As a matter of fact, an altered Horatio (copy) is not a copy of Horatio (perpetrator) at all, but rather some superficial resemblance, as close to an actual Horatio (copy) as the information Horatio enters into his IBM computer for some specific limited purpose. The real difference between the IBM and the altered Horatio (copy) is that the altered Horatio (copy) won't be a desk- top model and it will wear Air Force boots and khaki clothes. Sorry, Horatio, but sometimes the only way to acquire the values you desire is by doing it the old-fashioned way: humping through the jungle and putting your life on the line. If you step beyond the edge of the envelope, Alcor will try to be there so you don't get sent home in a body ga. P.S. -- Horatio and others will probably go to a fallback possession pursued through an investment in the Tyrel Corporation. Rumor has it that Tyrel intends to produce Nexus 6 replicants for dangerous off-world missions. Actually, this article has been written to insure my future job as a Blade Runner. I like long-term planning. Replies About Metamorphosis by Thomas Donaldson A few issues ago I discussed the notion of Uploading and its flaws. The flaws I described all stemmed from fundamental issues in computing and neurology. The major computing flaw comes directly from a need to port your brain (program): you could not be simply uploaded and run, any more than a 6502 game program uploaded onto a Cray would run. Porting requires rewriting the program in question; that rewriting raises many problems of identity. The major flaw in neurology stems from a ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (12) serious prospect that (as a program) you could not be run on ANY general- purpose computer. The circuits involved would differ too much. Of course, we might write a simulation. That would not be You but a simulated version of You. I had other objections to Uploading, too, but their discussion comes later. But I also presented a different scenario, Metamorphosis, which I believed would attain the same ends. It is not obvious to me why Ralph Merkle took objection to my arguments. In the latest installment (Cryonics, May 1991) Ralph continues his arguments. They take an odd line indeed, given that the central issue (I thought) was my arguments about flaws in Uploading. Instead, he proposes to instruct us in computer architecture and the definition of computers. Even supposing I were wrong on both counts, he still ignores the main points I raised about Uploading itself. I will discuss his computer points first; a few words on even more fundamental objections to Uploading will follow. Computer Architecture First, Ralph brings out a number of computers he claims have modifiable interconnections. His claim is simply false in most cases: the Intel Hypercube (and every other machine built on that architecture), the Ncube, and the TF-1 all have fixed interconnections. They do not switch, however much that switching is emulated in software, which it is. Others, such as the BBN Butterfly, do have modifiable connections. He mentioned that machines of this modifiable type have message passing times scaling as the order of N [O(N)] or O(log N) at best. This means of course that a direct message on a direct connection would pass N times faster (or perhaps log N times). The program running in you, however, is designed for a "computer" in which the message passing time is O(1), i.e. direct connection. This simple fact will force considerable rewriting of you. Furthermore, if we examine these bounds applied to synapses, just as Ralph says, we find some disagreeable results. If message passing scales 9 as O(N), then it may take 10 longer for some messages to pass on this computer than on our directly connected brain. If O(log N) it only takes maybe 9 times longer. So we see just what kinds of rewriting might be needed. I have been actually programming these beasts for five years, and during all of this time I've been reading up on them. Anyone who wishes to borrow any of my books on the subject is welcome, though often I simply use university libraries. Definition of Computers Pushing through all the high-sounding smoke (Turing machines and Church's Thesis), his discussion boils down to a bare statement that my chosen definition of computer is "incorrect" (i.e. nonstandard). Since I was not attempting to use any "standard definition" when I wrote my piece, I am surprised that any member of Alcor could be so dogmatic. Is this a religious orthodoxy? With his Turing machines Ralph makes much of the notion of "computational capability." Just what are we to take as "computational capability" anyway? The operations of a Turing machine are so simple we might train a rat to perform them on a real, physical ribbon. So this means that our "computational capability" equals that of the rat? Shall we enter into competition with IBM by selling office machines containing trained rats? I would want to look much deeper into the matter than abstract ideas about Turing machines and their capabilities. Of course the notion of Turing machines provides a useful abstract way to look at many issues in computing. But they do so by abstracting away very many traits of real computers which matter intensely to us: like speed, cost, physical size, and programming difficulty, among others. My points in this discussion depend essentially on this issue of just what "computational capability" is to mean. Since Dr. Merkle has yet to address this issue except by Turing machines, I shall make it real and material. I hereby offer to exchange, for every computer Dr. Merkle himself personally owns, either a used Apple II+ or a used Commodore 64 (my choice). Since Dr. Merkle assures us they are of "equivalent computational power" to a Cray I am sure that he will accept. Now of course we could simulate a human brain at some speed on almost any "computer," whatever that word means. (And note that an ability to be simulated on a computer does not make something a computer!) On computers which are large enough and fast enough, we can even do so down to timing, which I think is neglected in its importance: We are designed to deal with a real worlds, not a simulated universe, and our speeds match that real world. That's fine. But my original article was not about any ability to do that at all, but about what on Earth the point of it would be. So we have a poor little 6502 game emulated, right down to timing, on a Cray. How is this beneficial? Cryonics and Religion What bothers me most about Uploading is the smell of religion about it. Religious people have their immortality laid out for them. They need only contribute to their Church; their God will then solve all problems. And so, similarly, some devotees of Nanotechnology act as if they believe all our problems both with immortality and self-improvement will simply melt away. Perhaps my original article offended these devotees? To make any real improvements in ourselves we must examine and test every aspect, asking each time if the change retains those things about us that we want to keep. That is what I mean by Metamorphosis. "Uploading" is no more than an easy out, like translation to Heaven among deathists. Changing ourselves takes work, just like changing the outside world. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (13) Funding Cryonic Suspension -- A Critique by Howard S. Katz This article is the first of several dealing with the problem of providing inflation-resistant funding for cryonic suspension. Subsequent articles, by different authors, will explore possible solutions and obstacles in solving this difficult problem. The Threat to Cryonics Funding Cryonicists, by their nature, are continually fighting the battle of rational man in an irrational society. One respect in which our irrational society threatens cryonicists pertains to their funding arrangements, as follows. In the decade of the '70's, the amount of money in the United States doubled, causing the value of the currency to fall by half, which means that prices doubled. In the '80's, the amount of money doubled again; prices have not quite kept pace -- principally because we borrowed enormous amounts from the Germans and Japanese to maintain our lifestyles; however, I expect that the completion of this second doubling is just a few years away. Consider a person who has funded his cryonic suspension with a $120,000 whole-life insurance policy and who is currently in his mid-30's. He anticipates medical death in about four decades. The problem is that, during those four decades the currency will fall by half four times. That is to say, average prices will rise by 24 or 16 times, and the cost of cryonic suspension will be in the neighborhood of $2,000,000. (When I say that I expect the currency to fall by half for four successive decades, I am making a conservative assumption. The actual figure will depend on the integrity of the monetary authorities; however, as I will demonstrate below, the pressures to depreciate will increase with time so that the actual depreciation will probably be greater.) This rise in the cost of suspension would not in any way be the fault of the cryonics organizations. Indeed, I am assuming that, in real terms, their prices would remain the same. It would be a general social phenomenon, the decline in value of our money, affecting all economic goods. (It is for this reason that I prefer the term "currency depreciation" to describe the phenomena rather than "inflation." This emphasizes that something is wrong with the money in our society. The word "inflation" was used (starting about the time of the Civil War) to imply that goods were going up and that the blame lay with the goods.) The question is, what should a cryonicist who believes that he has funded his suspension properly and conservatively do? If he does nothing, then he is all too likely to wind up in the year 2031 at least $1,880,000 short. More likely, he will become aware of his shortfall incrementally. Each time his cryonics organization raises its nominal price (in order to keep its real price constant) he will respond with outrage. In this situation, it is all too common for the people in charge of prices to hold back needed price increases out of a misguided sense of ethics. This forces them to cut corners, to take risks, and to accept inferior products -- none of which you want to see when your life is at stake. The Cause of the Problem There is a solution to this problem. But before I present it, I want to explain the cause of currency depreciation in our society as expounded by the great theorists of the Austrian school of economics, in particular Ludwig Von Mises and Murray Rothbard. Once we have understood the cause, it will be easy to see our way to the cure. When modern banking systems arose out of the statism of the Middle Ages, credit was very poorly understood. Credit was defined as the price we pay for money, and to this day money and credit are confused by most economists. Money is a good which is universally exchangeable, meaning that anything in that society which is being offered for exchange will be exchangeable for the money. This brings us to the more difficult question, what is credit? I should first point out that a credit transaction can exist in a society which has no money. If Oog lends Og 10 arrows and receives the arrows back after the hunt plus 5% of the game, we have a bona fide credit transaction but no money has changed hands. It was the genius of the Austrian School of economics to discover that interest is the price we pay for time. Human beings have a time preference. They prefer to have their economic goods sooner rather than later. If I lend you the money for a new car, so that you get a car one year before I do, then if you repay the loan exactly, equity is not preserved. True, I have gotten my money back. But my time preference has been frustrated, and yours has been indulged. To compensate for this, you should pay me something extra, and this something extra is interest. Because money and credit were not understood, serious errors were made in the creation of the first banks. At this time the medieval superstition against all interest was under criticism but was still accepted by many people. As a compromise, the banks were allowed to charge interest when they made loans but were not allowed to pay interest to attract depositors. The way that they obtained deposits was as ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (14) follows. They offered to warehouse people's money (gold/silver coins) and gave in exchange a bank note, which was a piece of paper promising to pay the hard money on demand. Gradually, bank notes themselves became acceptable as money, and most of the hard money remained in the bank. Then, when someone came in for a loan, the bank would simply print up additional bank notes and lend them out. This led to situations wherein banks had far more bank notes promising hard money than they had hard money to give -- sometimes three or four times as much. But the bankers discovered that most people did not demand their hard money. Banking, or what we today call commercial banking, thus became a juggling act which required keeping three or four dollars in the air for every hard dollar in the vault. Every once in a while people would run to the banks and demand their hard money (e.g., 1815, 1861, 1933), and the banks would cry to the government to save them by suspending the rules of normal commerce (that a business enterprise has to keep its financial commitments). Thus, because money and credit were not understood, a system was created in which money was created out of nothing in the act of creating credit. This system existed until 1933; at which time it was made worse. FDR, despite his reputation as an enemy of bankers, gave the bankers what they most wanted: the ability to create money and credit without any connection at all to gold or silver. Since 1933, banks create money based on a reserve consisting of notes (or credit) of the Federal Reserve System; the Federal Reserve System prints these notes up as it desires, and the Federal Reserve is controlled by the very bankers who have a vested interest in creating more money. This new system thus had a built-in bias. The Federal Reserve continued to create more Federal Reserve notes (what we today think of as cash), and the commercial bankers continued to create money with the reserves thus acquired. Prior to 1933 the nation's money supply grew slowly and in pace with the population and supply of wealth so that there was no depreciation of the currency. By 1933, total money supply (demand deposits plus currency) was $20 billion. In the 48 years since that date, total money supply has grown to $840 billion. From 1793 to 1933, prices in this country remained approximately the same. From 1933 to the present, prices have multiplied by a factor of 10. A Credit Expansion -- How it Affects You Any cryonicist who is trying to plan his financial future four or five decades in advance must be aware of two crucial points: (1) the value of the currency is unstable; it is in the hands of the Federal Reserve, an organization which has proved itself extremely biased toward depreciation; and (2) the vested interests in favor of creating more money are extremely powerful and are at the present time in control of both major political parties. To understand this latter point, let us take a simple example of what happens in the real world when the Federal Reserve and the commercial bankers embark on a policy of money and credit expansion. Assume that the going rate of interest in the society is 5%. The bankers create money and offer it for loans. This additional supply lowers the rate of interest, say to 3%. But the rate of interest is not just a made-up number. As we have seen, it is a price -- the price for time. And as with any other price, a government attempt to manipulate the market results in bad consequences. Due to the lower rate of interest, there is now a greater demand for capital. Business has some projects which were put on the back burner because they only looked to make 4% on capital above the risk premium. Why invest to make 4% when you can make 5%? But now that rates are down to 3%, that 4% project is dusted off and put into practice, and this happens repeatedly throughout the economy. But at the same time that the demand for capital has increased, the supply has declined. Now that interest rates are lower the incentive to save is reduced. To make up the difference between the demand for capital and the supply of capital, the Federal Reserve and the banks create money (as described above) and funnel it into the capital markets (i.e., the banks lend the new money to business to finance the new projects). ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (15) Thus, in order to fund the new, lower, rate of interest, the Federal Reserve must continually print money and thus depreciate the currency. In general, a money and credit expansion benefits debtors and injures creditors. Creditors are hurt because the rate of interest is lowered, and they are hurt because their loans are repayed in dollars of depreciated value. This is of utmost importance to cryonicists because by funding suspension via whole-life insurance, you unwittingly become a creditor. That is, your insurance company takes your money and buys bonds. These bonds are fixed income obligations; they are paid off in a fixed number of dollars -- whether these dollars have depreciated or not. I once pointed this out to an insurance company executive. He shrugged his shoulders and replied, "It doesn't matter. Our obligations to our customers are fixed income. Our assets (bonds) match our liabilities (policies)." And indeed they do. But what that executive was saying to me was, if our customers are too stupid to understand that they are being cheated, then why should we care? It has been argued that, as the currency depreciates, bond yields will rise to keep pace with the depreciation. That is, a bond which normally yields 5% will increase its yield to 12% at a time when the currency is depreciating by 7%. Given enough time this would happen if the credit market were a free market. But the essence of the system is that the Federal Reserve (a government-empowered agency) interferes with the free market and always does so to lower the rate of interest. A few years ago I did a study covering the period 1933 to 1987 which assumed that an investor did nothing but buy U.S. Treasury bills, reinvested the interest, and paid no taxes. The currency depreciated so rapidly that at the end of this period an initial $1000 had shrunk to $870 in real value. This investor was receiving negative interest. The problem is complicated by the fact that the Government's Consumer Price Index is no longer a good measure of the rate at which prices are rising. It was clearly rising too fast in 1979-80 and too slowly in mid- decade. Also, the vested interests which benefit from currency depreciation have on occasion altered the index to make it rise less rapidly and thus make "inflation" appear to be less than is. I find the money supply to be a more accurate measure of the rate at which the currency is depreciating, and on this basis I estimate that the U.S. dollar is losing value at a rate of 7% per year. At this writing, U.S. Treasury bills, the only risk-free investment, are yielding 6%. This means that any investor must either assume some risk or else see his capital decrease by 1% per year (before taxes). And this means that any promises made to you by an insurance company are an illusion. At the end of 40 or 50 years they [insurance companies] may give you back a much larger nominal sum than what you have put in, but in real terms it will be the same or smaller. What are the chances that the currency depreciation will stop? Unfortunately, there are powerful vested interests that want to keep it going. The bankers naturally benefit because it enables them to make more loans. But all debtors benefit, and this primarily includes big business, the nation's biggest debtor. Most important, these businesses got overextended during the expansion. They put themselves in a position where the expansion must continue just so that they do not lose ground. If the expansion stops, they will go bankrupt. Periodically there are fitful attempts to stop the expansion. It usually results in the bankruptcy of a few major companies. Then political pressure is brought to bear, and the expansion is resumed. In 1969, an attempt was made to stop the expansion. The budget was balanced, and the increase in the money supply was brought down from 7% per year to 2% per year. The Penn-Central Railroad went bankrupt, and Chrysler was only weeks away from bankruptcy when the Federal Reserve began to print money at an aggressive pace. In 1973-74, there was another attempt; this time it was New York City which went to the verge of bankruptcy. (Both Chase-Manhattan and Citibank were holding large amounts of NYC bonds.) In 1981, it was Chrysler again. Each time the Federal Reserve averted a business crisis by resuming the money and credit expansion. I cannot say for sure that some future generation of Americans will not stop this process; but I can say that to do so they will have to overcome a large and powerful vested interest, an interest which has not been defeated over the past 58 years. Furthermore, each time we go through a cycle, these companies become more dependent on the expansion. They need a bigger and bigger expansion of money and credit to resume their former profitability. Thus the rate of money growth has continually increased, from 1-2% per year in the '50s to 4% per year in the '60s to 6% per year in the '70s to over 7% per year in the '80s. At this writing, the monetary base is increasing at a rate of 18% per year (over the past three months), and it is not hard to predict that the money supply itself will follow. The Solution So much for the bad news. The good news is that proper financial management can overcome this problem. In the 19th century, when the U.S. was on a gold standard, the currency did not depreciate, and high grade bonds yielded 5% per year. Money invested at this 5% rate over a 40 year period of time multiplied by a factor of 7. This was a real return, not merely a nominal one. Assuming that we could earn 5% per year real return, then a cryonicist who was 40 years from medical death would have to invest $17,142.86 to earn his $120,000. If he does not have a lump sum, he can contribute monthly from his salary. Assuming that the average monthly contribution comes at the 20 year mark, it will multiply by 2.65 in real terms, and to earn $120,000 for his suspension, he only has to contribute $45,227. This works out to a monthly payment of $94.22. (Note that these figures are in 1991 dollars. By the 16:1 assumption at the beginning of this article, final suspension cost in 40 years would be $1,920,000, and the last monthly payment would be $1507.52. This $1507.52, however, would represent the same proportion of his monthly salary as the $94.22 does today -- assuming that he kept the same job.) But is it possible to earn 5% real rate of return on capital in this day and age as it was in the 19th century? The answer is yes. The key is to realize that the money and credit expansion steals wealth from ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (16) the creditor but gives it to the debtor. This means that it takes wealth from the bondholders of a corporation and gives it to the stockholders. Since 1933, stocks have averaged almost a 12% real rate of return (including dividends and discounting for currency depreciation). By owning stocks, you shift yourself from the exploited class to the exploiting class in terms of capital, and lay the basis for a realistic savings program. Owning stocks as opposed to bonds is part of the strategy of wise investing in a paper money era. It involves taking some additional risk, but this risk is absolutely essential. When Congress passed the first paper money legislation in 1933, they made it impossible to make real gains in capital by investing in any fixed income stocks. Those people who buy bonds, notes, bills, money market accounts, insurance, or bank savings accounts are engaged in self-deception. They are gaining in nominal dollars, but they are losing in real dollars. The second part of the strategy takes advantage of a fairly regular cycle in the creation of money and credit. The good effects of an expansion, the benefits flowing to business and the banks, are apparent almost immediately after the expansion starts. It is normal that 2-6 months after interest rates start falling, the stock market bottoms and starts to move up. Whereas, the bad effects of an expansion, the emotional bubbles which outrage the community and the general rise in prices, are only apparent after a time lag, a lag which is sometimes several years. For example, the Reagan years were years of massive money creation. The money supply grew by 9% in 1983, by 12% in 1985, and by 18% in 1986. All three of these years topped the worst Carter year (8+ in 1978). Yet we have not had to date a corresponding increase in prices because the Germans and Japanese, via the trade gap, have been lending us a large quantity of goods. Now that the trade gap is being reduced, prices are picking up, and when it is completely eliminated, we will see outrageous price increases. In the early years, when the authorities see only the good effects, they encourage the credit expansion. When they see the bad effects, they make belated efforts to stop or slow the expansion. In the first phase, of which 1975-77 and 1981-86 are examples, interest rates go down and stocks (and other capital goods) go up. In the second phase, e.g., 1972-74 and 1979-81, interest rates go up and stocks tend to go down. This suggests an obvious strategy. Invest in conservative stocks or other capital goods during the expansionary phase. Then when the authorities try to slow the expansion, invest in Treasury bills (or similar instruments) to get the high interest rates which result. It is such periods (e.g., 1979-81) which are an exception to the rule that fixed income obligations are a losing game. Then when the authorities are changing back to an expansionary policy (e.g., 1981), switch from Treasury bills into Treasury bonds to lock in the high interest rates and also to benefit from the price gains in the bonds. The final phase of the strategy is to switch into stocks or other capital goods to capture the gains from that part of the cycle. Fortunately, with some experience it is not too difficult to catch these turning points and determine where the Federal Reserve authorities are at each point. Often whey will openly declare their policy. When Alan Greenspan announced on the evening of Black Monday that he would provide "liquidity" to the system; this was economicese for printing money. It was a dead giveaway that the larger collapse and economic catastrophe which was widely forecast at the time would not come and that the stock market would rally. I went in and bought stocks aggressively on the following day and was rewarded with profits over the next two years. Even when the authorities do not announce their policy, one can see it by watching their actions. And easing is indicated when the Federal Reserve buys Government bonds (more aggressively than normal), interest rates move down, short-term rates move down more rapidly than long and reserves pile up in the banking system. A tightening is indicated when the Fed sells Government bonds (or buys them less aggressively than normal), interest rates move up, short- term rates move up more rapidly than long, and the bankers are tight for reserves. So the second part of the strategy involves watching the Federal Reserve and the economy and trying to be in the right investment at the right time. In the period of tight credit, as in 1979-81, you want to be in Treasury bills. When credit starts to ease, as in 1982, you want to shift into Treasury bonds. As the easing picks up speed, you would naturally shift into conservative stocks or other capital goods. (Determining which capital good is most likely to benefit is another question which is beyond the scope of this article.) I describe this policy by saying that we are in a system which produces continual financial earthquakes. The financial ground shifts under our feet continually, pushing one investment up and another down. This is because money, which is half of every economic transaction, is not stable. By Austrian theory, one can predict how the ground will shift, which sectors will go up and which will go down. It is then simply a matter of shifting one's assets in a conservative manner so that one is in the sector which is going up. Such a program is more "risky" in the conventional sense, but in a paper money society the "safe" investments are investments which suffer a continual loss in real terms. Those who wish a perfectly safe investment which yields a fair rate of return should work toward the re-establishment of a gold standard. Using these principles of money management, a conservative fund could be set up to manage money for cryonicists for their suspension. This would ensure that your hard-earned money was not dissipated by the depreciation of the currency and that upon medical death you would be able to afford suspension. The same principles could also be used to manage a more conventional fund for those who wanted to save money for more conventional purposes (such as retirement). In this way you would no longer be the victim of our corrupt money system. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (17) Dr. Bedford Gets a New Suit by Ralph Whelan ** PHOTO SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "The morning briefing. Hugh Hixon describes the various steps and a rough timeline. L to R: Tanya Jones, Russell Whitaker (sitting), Carlos Mondragon, Hugh Hixon, Ralph Whelan, Jerry Leaf, Allen Lopp, Michael perry (mostly obscured by Al Lopp), Max More, Bill Seidel." ** James Bedford was the first man to be frozen. A dubious honor at best in 1967, when the word "cryonics" was only two years old, and Eric Drexler had notions other than molecular assemblers on his teen-age mind. Now, though, nearly twenty-five years cold, Dr. Bedford and his motivations are a bit better understood, at least by those who care to understand such dramatic undertakings. Cryonicists now have a wing and a prayer and some promising research data to go on, speculations on reanimation techniques are sprouting mathematical symbols, and the world in general is somewhat of a better place for the "metabolically challenged" (i.e., frozen). These were the thoughts occupying my mind, as thirteen of us gathered one Saturday morning late in May, 1991. Why, just think of what we'd rallied to do: we were moving the first man ever frozen from his aged storage unit -- Twenty-one years worn -- and putting him into a new, efficient, four-person, state-of-the-art dewar. He would get an additional sleeping bag for thermal protection. He would rest in an individual aluminum pod for mechanical and further thermal protection. He would nest efficiently, sharing liquid nitrogen with three others, and sharing a Patient Care Bay with thirteen more, with a full-time on-site caretaker, temperature alarms. . . . His care was improving. After twenty-four years in storage, more years than I've been alive, rather than declining into sporadic attempts to avoid what once must have seemed inevitable, his care was getting better. What an encouraging and heartening sign for someone who as likely as not will end up in a similar state someday. This was the stew-pot on one "back burner" of my mind, as I drank coffee and listened to Hugh Hixon explain the elaborate dance routine that would get Dr. Bedford out of his horizontal home of twenty-one years and into his new suit. The other mental burner, a much bigger burner, was devoted to the same anxiety that must of have been niggling at twelve other forebrains at the very same moment: ** PHOTO SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "Donning the protective gear. Liquid nitrogen splashes are unavoidable in transfers and encapsulations." ** ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (18) ** PHOTO SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "The inner shell is a bit more tricky, with vapors obscuring vision and liquid nitrogen spraying out. Further, as the nitrogen level drops near Dr. Bedford's feet, his biological clock starts ticking once again, though he is still very cold." ** When the lid dropped, when the bag lifted, when the vapor cleared, what were we going to find? How relentless were Dr. Bedford's caretakers during the sixteen years before he came under Alcor's care? Could anyone not building a business and a career around such persistent care possibly have stamina and fortitude enough to never screw up? Was James Hiram Bedford not just legally dead, not just medically dead, but now also dead dead? (I.e., were the brain structures essential to his memories and identity eradicated?) We didn't know. And the name "James Bedford," after twenty-four years of capital-P Pioneerness, has accumulated a lot of emotional and intellectual baggage for a lot of people. Although far from conventional icon status, he represents a level of achievement and commitment to principle in the cryonics community that -- still reeling from the Chatsworth incident -- would sag horribly if it turned out that the First Man had fallen. (I wish I were overstating the point.) With this heightened level of anticipation -- that feeling of being present for some Special Moment in history -- we fidgeted through the nine A.M. briefing. This gradually devolved into into the assignment of preparatory parts-assembly and clutter-clearing tasks, which took the better part of an hour. Final preparations consisted of dressing for our parts. Those who would be physically transferring Bedford (Mike Darwin, Hugh Hixon, Jerry Leaf, Allen Lopp, Max More, Ralph Whelan, Russell Whitaker) donned cover-all rain suits to protect against liquid nitrogen splashes. This done, we deferred to experience. Jim Amato, owner/operator of CryoTech (the cryogenic repair company that gets our business) and expert handler of abrasive cutting wheels, hunkered down to the tricky task of cutting through the weld on Bedford's dewar. Brief Dewar Lecture: the old- time storage dewars were welded (or bolted) shut to preserve a vacuum between the inner and outer steel shells. Reflective foil situated within this vacuum provides additional insulation. Cutting through the outer shell would expose nothing but the reflective foil, but was tricky still in that Jim (and we) wanted to make as much cutting progress as we could without breaking the seal, since losing the vacuum would greatly compromise our thermal protection and increase the rate of liquid nitrogen boil-off. We weren't chained to the clock yet, but we were thinking about it. Jim spent about twenty-five minutes cutting evenly around the outer shell, while antsy cryonicists approached and receded. Scant minutes after the first hiss of inrushing air, the lid of the outer shell dropped away. We were rewarded with mounds of Dimplar foil -- a dimpled insulator produced by a now-defunct company -- and, with a little digging, the bare, cold surface of the inner shell. The inner shell quickly began to frost over, revealing the "water line," so to speak, of the liquid level inside. Jim set to work on the inner weld, while behind him the procession of anxious cryonicists stepped up in tempo. Minutes later, when he broke through the inner shell, a plume of nitrogen vapor marked the occasion dramatically. Later still, as he widened the breach around the perimeter of the lid, the ** PHOTO SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "Now we work fast. Restraining bolts are removed and Dr. Bedford is quickly transferred into a waiting liquid nitrogen bath. Dr. Perry, in the background, records exposure time and assorted historical moments." ** ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (19) ** PHOTO SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "Here the antiquated but adequate racking system is exposed. THe ropes had secured Dr. Bedford to the tray; what appear as paper scraps were actually 'Dimplay' foil, an insulation material." ** nitrogen began escaping in liquid form, and quickly, and we could see by the frost line on the inner shell that Dr. Bedford's biological clock would soon be ticking again. It was the "feet" end of the dewar that was raised, so the brain was surely still immersed, but no warming is good warming. (Here follows a brief interval of finger-flexing and foot-stomping for twelve ischemia-hating Alcorians, their anxiety squared and cubed by the unfairness of still not knowing if there was even anything to be nervous about anymore. Jim, would you get that damned thing open!) He did get it open, and expertly so. And here we got our first surprise: the stretcher, or more precisely the metal frame holding Dr. Bedford, was bolted to the slide! After a quick scramble for a couple of wrenches, the bolts were loosened. As we stepped aside, Jim and Hugh began working to loosen the bolts holding the racking system that supported Bedford. Once Jim and Hugh loosened these, we were able to slide the rack almost entirely out, revealing a pale blue sleeping bag secured to the rack with Nylon rope. Then we got our second surprise: another set of bolts anchoring the rack to the slide on the the other end! A quick decision was made to simply cut Bedford free from the rack and lift him in the sleeping bag. As Mike had a pair of Superscissors in his pocket, this went rapidly. So rapidly in fact that the sleeping bag was still soaked with liquid nitrogen when we picked it up. This was the first installment in a collection of minor liquid nitrogen burns for most of the transfer participants. Since we knew well ahead of time that we would want to evaluate Bedford's condition, and that we could not risk him warming while we did so, Hugh had engineered a heavily insulated bathtub, of sorts, to facilitate this. What we had, in effect, was a galvanized steel tank filled with liquid nitrogen and surrounded by about a foot of expanded polystyrene foam. This created a bath that would allow us to a) assess Bedford's condition and determine whether or not he had ever been allowed to warm significantly, while keeping him submerged and cool, and b) perform the various mechanical manipulations that would allow us to get a second sleeping bag around him for thermal protection and an aluminum pod around him for mechanical protection, while again keeping him submerged for most of the operation. So we had the liquid nitrogen bath waiting nearby. We rushed Bedford over to the bath and immediately submerged him. After taking a breather and relaxing a bit, we began unzipping the pale-blue bag that covered him. With a minimum of lifting and thermal exposure (some is necessary to access the zipper), we worked it open. With the billowing clouds of water vapor condensing from the air as a result of peeling back the sleeping bag, it was difficult at first to see him clearly, but eventually the air cleared enough that we were able to see. As you might be able to tell from the accompanying pictures, there was quite an expectant and eager gathering. After (for some) years to decades of wondering and hoping, we were at last able to satisfy ourselves that the news was nothing but good. Dr. Bedford, it would seem, had been attended to diligently over the preceding decades. Looking at him, we could say with certainty (and the ultimate ** PHOTO SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "This is a crew of relieved cryonicists. Dr. Bedford -- once again submerged in liquid nitrogen -- looks as good as we could've hoped." ** ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (20) ** PHOTO SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "This rigging system and bath, engineered by Hugh Hixon, allows us to transfer patients into sleeping bags and aluminum pods with only brief removal from liquid nitrogen." ** in satisfaction) that his temperature in degrees Celsius had remained negative -- had not risen above zero -- during the past twenty-four years. (For a technical description of Dr. Bedford's condition, see the following piece by Mike Darwin: Evaluation of the Condition of Dr. James H. Bedford After 24 Years of Cryonic Suspension.) Once the tension was sufficiently eased and we were prepared to finish the job, Hugh rolled a modified engine hoist -- sort of an overhead jack assembly -- to a central position over the bath. Along with a special strongback mount Hugh designed to lift the entire length of the patient evenly, this would allow us to hoist Bedford out of the nitrogen long enough to run a second sleeping bag beneath him. Despite protective gloves, liquid nitrogen still manages to get through the seams; everyone got their second set of liquid nitrogen burns at this juncture. During all of the time that Bedford was out of the bath, his original sleeping bag provided thermal protection, while Russell and Max doused him continually with buckets of liquid nitrogen. We returned him to the bath. Prior to the whole operation, Hugh had placed straps across the bottom of the bath and up over the edges. These were now used to snug the second sleeping bag. We were then able to use them as lifting straps as we hoisted Bedford once again, this time to slide first some straps and then half of an aluminum pod beneath him, while Russell and Max continued to bail nitrogen from the bath onto Bedford. Again we lowered him. We loosened the hoist from the sleeping bag and affixed it to the straps running beneath the pod bottom. Lifting only slightly, we were able to expose enough of the pod rim to slide the pod top into place and bolt it down. I'm making this sound a bit smoother than it actually was; as one would expect there was every manner of minor hang-up and contingency, but the gist of each maneuver we accomplished. Having run the thermocouple lines out a special port in the pod and having secured the top half of the pod "clamshell," we prepared to hoist the pod into a vertical position, with Bedford securely strapped within the pod head-down. This is the trickiest part of the operation, since the patient will not be submerged and hence we must move quickly, while at the same time we're moving quite a weighty package, which is quite cold to boot. The sleeping bags and pod provide tremendous thermal protection of the patient during such moves, but time is still of the essence. We maneuvered one of the "Bigfoot" dewars into position next to the bath. (This dewar then held only one other patient, our most recent suspension, already in a protective pod.) After hooking a lift bar to the pod and hooking it to an overhead electric winch, we began carefully hoisting the pod, while Max and Russell used a guide bar to prevent dragging as we worked it upright. We then managed, relatively quickly and efficiently, to raise the pod and then lower it into the Bigfoot. And that was it. The historical First Man had his new suit, as well as a team of very happy tailors. At this rate of improvement in care, another twenty-five years will see Dr. Bedford's ultimate transfer! ** PHOTO SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "When the patients are out of the nitrogen, the sleeping bags keep the air away and the liquid around the patient, while dedicated cryonicists like Max More continuously saturate the bag." ** ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (21) ** PHOTO SPACE ** ** CAPTIONS -- "Mike (standing center) runs the crane while Hugh guides the top of the pod (where the patient's feet are) and Max and Russell guide the bottom. Ralph looks on approvingly." ** "Pod Jockeys Ralph and Mike guide the tricky descent into the dewar. The pod system makes for a tight fit, for stability. The wires visible at the top of the pod are thermocouple (temperature) probes." ** "The pods nest together very well, as this picture illustrates. The square centerpiece is a racking system with shelves for neuropatients or pets. All pieces are aluminum, with liquid nitrogen vents, straps for stability, and lift mounts on the 'top.' (Remember that the patients are secured head- down.)" ** ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (22) Evaluation of the Condition of Dr. James H. Bedford After 24 Years of Cryonic Suspension by Mike Darwin Introduction On 12 January, 1967, Dr. James H. Bedford became the first man to enter cryonic suspension. The story of his suspension and his care over the intervening years is covered elsewhere (1,2,3). The purpose of this article is to document Dr. Bedford's condition as assessed by a brief external exam conducted on 25 May, 1991. At this time, Dr. Bedford was transferred from the horizontal sealed-in-the-field (Galiso, Inc.) cryogenic dewar -- into which he had been welded in April of 1970 -- to a state-of-the-art multipatient dewar. Removal From The Dewar At approximately 09:30 on 25 May the foot end of the dewar containing the patient was elevated on concrete blocks, effectively submerging the patient's head and torso. Beginning at about 10:00 AM, an abrasive cutting wheel was used to open the outer shell of the dewar, in the process breaking the vacuum (at 10:15). The outer head was then removed and the reflective barrier in the annulus between the inner and outer cans, consisting of multiple layers of dimpled aluminized mylar (Dimplar), was torn away. The inner head was then opened by an abrasive cutting wheel; this process was completed at 10:55. The metal framework (bed) supporting the patient was then slid out of the unit. The patient, contained in a sleeping bag, was freed from the bed by cutting the nylon rope securing him to it. The patient was then transferred to an insulated, open-topped bath of liquid nitrogen for examination and evaluation. In order to avoid any possibility of rewarming, the patient was evaluated while submerged in liquid nitrogen. The necessity of conducting the examination under these conditions limited its scope. Evaluation External visual examination discloses a well-developed, well nourished male who appears younger than his 73 years. The skin on the upper thorax and neck appears discolored and erythematous from the mandible to approximately two cm. above the areolas. The area of discoloration is fairly sharply demarcated on the thorax. The head is turned to the left and two puncture marks are noted approximately 1 cm apart over the anteriomedial aspect of the sternocleidomastoid muscle (approximately paralelling the internal carotid artery). These puncture marks are clot- free and present a fresh, "cored" appearance (suggesting a large-bore needle). The skin on the left side of the neck is distended with what appears to be a fluid bolus(es) injected into the subcutaneous space. The position of the patient's head precludes careful examination of the skin for puncture marks on the left side. There is frozen blood issuing from the mouth and nose. A smear of bright-red blood covers the skin around the nose and mouth in a pattern which appears to have been defined by a respirator mask. A larger quantity of darker red blood appears to have flowed out of the mouth during freezing to dry ice temperature, as it retains the ** PHOTO SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "Opening the outer head of the dewar: an abrasive cutting wheel was used to score the weld before cutting completely through the outer can and breaking the vacuum." ** ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (23) ** PHOTO SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "The patient submerged in liquid nitrogen. A piece of liquid nitrogen saturated, open-cell urethane foam was used to provide thermal protection for the top of the patient's thorax where it projected out of the liquid nitrogen. Note the smears of blood around the mouth and nose and the discoloration of the skin of the upper thorax, which presents a 'scalded' appearance." ** folds and contours of the wrapping material which presumably covered the patient's face during freezing. The eyes are partially open and the corneas are chalk-white from ice. The nares are flattened out against the face, apparently as a result of being compressed by a slab of dry ice during initial freezing. The head is fringed with short-cropped, uniformly gray hair. Several small pieces of adherent aluminized mylar are present on the occiput. The skin on the ventral thorax, abdomen, and limbs appears free of lesions and of normal color with the following exception: the right forearm and hand appear discolored and erythematous and appear to be the site of an intravenous line or subcutaneous injection of a hemolytic or irritating product. Most of the abdomen and thorax were covered with a thin, transparent, polyethylene sheet which was reflected back to facilitate examination. The chest is covered with sparse gray hair. Close examination of the skin on the chest over the pectoral area disclosed sinuous features that appeared to be fractures. When these were probed under the liquid with a spinal needle it was noted that the skin was discontinuous over these areas. Subsequently, two small samples of skin were secured from the edges of one of these "fractures" with the gentle use of a wood chisel. The samples are currently being maintained in liquid nitrogen vapor for subsequent ultrastructural evaluation. It is noted that in addition to the presence of unmelted water ice obscuring the genitals, there was another mass of unmelted water ice between the right arm and abdomen, just above the pelvis. A part of this ice mass was lifted free with a spinal needle and was observed to still retain some of the original small cube structure, attesting to the fact that it had not been warmed above 0C. The genitals are not visible due to the presence of unmelted water ice which anchors the plastic film. The lower legs are crossed with the right foot over the left. There is aluminized mylar tape, of the kind used to secure superinsulation inside cryogenic dewars, wrapped around the toes of both feet. This tape was removed for examination; upon rewarming the tape retained its adhesive properties. It is presumed this tape was placed after cooling to -79C for the purpose of anchoring thermocouple probes used to monitor temperature descent in the Cryo-Care storage unit (4). Owing to the need to maintain the patient submerged in liquid nitrogen, and the logistic aspects attendant to his transfer from one dewar to another, the dorsal aspect of the body was not examined. ** PHOTO SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "View of the patient's thorax and abdomen. The edge of the erythematous area can be seen at the extreme left. A sheet of polyethylene plastic covers the body from the axilla to the groin. Note the water ice present between the forearm and abdomen as well as the 'ridge' of ice (retaining the shape of the original wrapping) running down the dorsal surface of the arm." ** ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (24) ** PHOTO SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "Ice mass removed from between right arm and abdomen (suspended on a spinal needle above the liquid nitrogen bath containing the patient). Some of the original small cubed structure is still visible." ** Conclusions Overall this examination indicates that the patient has at least not been warmed above 0C. Further, the presence of undenatured hemoglobin as evidenced by the presence of bright red blood, and the appearance of the water ice remaining on the patient, including what appeared to be loose (i.e., unrecrystalized) condensed "frost" from his cooling to -79C suggests that rewarming was not to any high subzero temperature (i.e., it seems likely that his external temperature has remained at relatively low subzero temperatures throughout the storage interval). Given the patient's thermal history, which consists of nearly a decade and a half of cycling between liquid nitrogen vapor temperature at 80K and liquid nitrogen temperature at 77K, and at least two previous instances of removal from cryogenic storage and transient exposure to ambient temperature while being transferred from storage dewar to storage dewar, it is not surprising that he should show evidence of surface fracturing. In 1983, during examination of another patient converted from whole body to neurosuspension who had been previously rewarmed to -79C and then cooled to -196C a second time, external fractures were also noted (5). However, one marked dissimilarity between the fractures present in that patient and those present in this one was that the skin in the former patient had separated from the underlying tissues in spots, sometimes presenting a "peeling paint" appearance. This phenomenon was not observed to have occurred with this patient. It is assumed that the erythematous discoloration observed in the skin of the jaw, neck, upper thorax, and right arm were as a result of the hypodermic injection of highly concentrated cryoprotectant solution or perhaps pure dimethylsulfoxide as has been reported by Nelson (6) and Prehoda (7). It is the author's opinion that the nature of the discoloration is due to hemolysis from this agent(s). Bloody fluid issuing from the mouth and nose was a not completely unanticipated finding; photos made during the patient's transfer from the Cryo-Care storage vessel to the Galiso unit in 1970 suggest this. The character of this fluid appears to be whole blood, ruling out purging of gastric contents (an early post-mortem sign of decomposition) as a cause. The source of this blood is presumed to be pulmonary hemorrhage secondary to prolonged cardiopulmonary resuscitation and friable lungs as a result of the extensive pulmonary metastases which were the proximate cause of deanimation. It is well-established that pulmonary edema is a common consequence of prolonged closed chest cardiopulmonary resuscitation clinically (8) as well as in prolonged cardiopulmonary support of cryonic suspension patients using closed chest cardiac compression (9). References 1) Nelson, R.F. and Stanley, S., We Froze The First Man, Dell Publishing Co., Inc., New York, 1968. 2) Nelson, R.F., Personal communication, 23 September, 1982 3) Darwin, M.G., "Dear Dr. Bedford", Cryonics, 12(7), 15-22 (1991). 4) Kraver, T., Personal communication, 3 June, 1991. 5) Federowicz, M., Hixon, H., and Leaf J., "Post-mortem examination of three cryonic suspension patients." Cryonics, (September, 1984). 6) Nelson, R.F., Personal communication, 23 September, 1982. 7) Prehoda, R., Unpublished interview conducted in May, 1983. 8) Ornato, J.P., et al., "Measurement of ventilation during cardiopulmonary resuscitation." Crit. Care Med., 11(2), 79-82 (1983). 9) Unpublished case histories of Alcor patients A-1103 and A-1036. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (25) A Lesson From Political Experience by Allen J. Lopp I may appear to be trying to pass myself off as an expert at political lobbying, but actually I am quite the neophyte. At times I have been a hanger-on in some non-cryonics organizations which gave me the chance to watch others do lobbying and political action, so I have been exposed to the logic and tactics involved. My personal experience is light, although my interest is high. Undoubtedly a longer track record can be claimed by several Alcor members that have been active in the National Space Society and its precursor organizations. H. Keith Henson, Alcor member and CEL president, was a founder of the L-5 Society in the mid-70's and was one of the leaders in the successful fight against the UN Moon Treaty. More recently, some Alcor members can be counted among a virtual handful of space activists that were successful at lobbying the Space Transportation Services Purchase Act through Congress. This Act, which authorizes NASA to purchase launch capability from private firms in certain cases, was incorporated as Title II of the last NASA Authorization Bill and is now law. Alcor members that participated in this lobbying effort include Keith Henson, Mark Voelker, Kurt Schoedel, David Brandt-Erichsen (who is, by the way, an NSS Director) and Alcor Director Brenda Peters. Mark Voelker wrote a thoughtful letter to me earlier this year about how the experience the NSS lobbyists learned could be applied to cryonics lobbying. I'd like to share a portion of his letter with you now. I have not changed any of Mark's words, although I have changed the formatting somewhat, putting his points into a bulleted list: "I think it's time to begin political action in support of cryonics (consider the recent legislation outlawing cryonics in British Columbia). However, we cannot start any sort of public campaign for pro-cryonics legislation until several things have been accomplished. -- First, we need to decide what we want in the way of legislation, both ideally and in the event of the inevitable compromises that are part of the political process. -- Second, we need to identify which organs of government will, and in our view should, have jurisdiction over cryonics and related activities. This includes identifying the committees and subcommittees in the legislature that will consider our legislation and the politicians that sit on those committees, and also the agencies and bureaucrats in the executive branch that will enforce cryonics legislation. -- Third, we need to identify potential allies and opponents. -- Fourth, we need to develop a network of activists that possess the necessary levels of personal maturity and motivation to carry through to success a project that will require a light to moderate level of activity sustained over several years. -- Finally, those activists need to volunteer to work for various candidates and causes in both major parties to gain access to politicians and their aides, to gather political intelligence, and to learn the political process. "None of the above requires a lot of money, though people are more easily induced to help out if expenses for telephone calls and printing and mailing and the like are reimbursed by an organization such as CEL. Thus CEL can leverage its resources by using volunteer labor if it can cover people's out-of-pocket expenses (but this requires sufficiently motivated activists). My experience with space legislation runs counter to the popular view that political influence is gained most effectively by making campaign contributions. I think that large contributions often serve as a form of political "damage control" on the part of people and organizations that are trying late in the game to derail well planned efforts by groups that are well integrated into the political power structure. We need to be pro- active, not reactive. "The Space Transportation Services Purchase Act became law through the efforts of about a dozen activists, working for four years with a budget of a few hundred dollars per year -- although we would have done much better with ten times that much money. I think our success was due to; 1) our willingness to help out during the campaign season with grunt work such as stuffing envelopes; 2) our reasonableness, credibility and high level of preparedness when discussing our needs with politicians; 3) our ability to listen to others and take at least a nominal interest in their reasons for being involved in politics; 4) a low level of political infighting and power struggles within our group ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (26) (we just did what needed to be done according to who could do the job at the time); 5) a recognition on the part of most of us that the reward for our efforts would not be fame or fortune right away but the creation of a more positive climate several years hence for accomplishing our goals; 6) the basic fact that we were right and correct in what we were trying to do, and weren't just trying to steal money from the taxpayers or otherwise slant the system unfairly in our favor; and finally 7) good luck. The last point can be made less important with more money and people on your side, but beware -- organizations with big budgets and memberships tend to get bogged down in organizational formalities and political squabbling over money and power. Just ask Keith Henson about the fate of the National Space Society." I really appreciate Mark's letter because I could hardly imagine a better blueprint on how to proceed to advocate pro-cryonics legislation on a truly modest budget. I anticipate, however, that there are major differences between lobbying for a space cause and lobbying for pro-cryonics legislation. Everyone knows that NASA exists and that space missions are a reality, although voters may disagree on whether space exploration is a good idea. With cryonics, however, the average man-on-the-street (or woman, or lawmaker, even) knows only the most basic idea, and often has been exposed to a lot of misinformation and negative "spin" on that information. While space lobbyists deal with lawmakers on the details of how to do space exploration, cryonics advocates must first deal with their question: Everybody knows cryonics is crazy -- why should I act to protect it? The most obvious approach is to first try to convince them that cryonics is a reasonable pursuit, even though the average Joe may assume it's crazy. Then, once this is done, there is another problem to deal with: Will the legislator be willing to support something his average constituent thinks is crazy, weird, anti-social, or ill advised? The amount of education needed is formidable, on an issue that some will refuse to be educated about. For this reason again, I expect it is best to champion cryonics as a civil right rather than a course of action likely to achieve scientific success. This is also the easiest way for lawmakers to justify their support to their constituents. But no matter what approach we emphasize, it's clear to me that as cryonics advocates we have a lot of talking to do. All the more reason to begin now. Star Wars Trilogy, Computer Games, and Expansion Bridges Made of Diamond Fibers by Linda Chamberlain Brian hesitates at the door. The gold letters on the smoked glass read: "Pamela Palmer, M.D., Ph.D., Neuroprosthetics". His heart rate soars. I must be insane, he says to himself, to let my friends badger me into this! He takes a deep breath and opens the door. The nurse smiles, greets him, and asks him to have a seat. It's a perfectly ordinary smile, but it irritates him. He feels too warm as he looks around for a chair as far from others as possible in the waiting room. The last thing he wants right now is a conversation with some boob mad enough to actually replace some part of his brain. The thought makes him wince. Even before he gets comfortably hidden behind a magazine, that happy- faced nurse calls his name. His head is light as he follows her down a corridor of doors closed tight against prying eyes. (Or maybe they were locked to keep the smart ones from running for their lives.) The nurse stops at an open door and gestures for him to wait inside. He straightens his clothes and enters, determined not to reveal his discomfort. The nurse smiles again as she turns to leave. Bet she thinks I'm a real pushover. But I'll show them! I can walk in here, listen to their best arguments, and then walk right out again. There is nothing to be afraid of. This is, after all, a free society. I don't have to have a brain prosthetic if I don't want one. He thinks about the friends who pressured him into coming. Alain, his best friend, had his cerebellum replaced. The lunatic! Says his coordination is far superior. Well, maybe he can beat me at tennis now, but who cares, anyway. And Mariza, now she's a knockout. Even wanted to date her. . . 'til I found she'd had some unpronounceable area on the side of brain replaced to improve her writing and verbal communication. Gad! What's the world coming to? Have they all gone insane? A noise at the door. Dr. Palmer paces briskly into the room and introduces herself. At least she doesn't have a plastic smile like the nurse! He feels better, but can't afford to lose the upper hand. He rushes to let her know he wants no part of his brain removed and no foreign parts placed into it. "I like my brain just the way it is," he tells her firmly. To his surprise, she listens. She assures him he is not alone in his feelings and that neither she nor anyone on her staff will try to persuade him to accept anything he's not comfortable with. He begins to relax but reminds himself that it could be a trick. Grudgingly, he agrees to watch a video about the evolution of the human brain. Dr. Palmer explains that he can make another appointment after seeing the video if he changes his mind and wants to explore the prospect of neuroprosthetics. She asks him to pay particular attention to the concepts of consciousness continuity which will be discussed. As Dr. Palmer leaves the room, Brian feels en- ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (27) gulfed by the loss of her reassuring presence. In "The Origin of Consciousness" in the "Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind" (8), Julian Jaynes addresses the mystery and wonder we feel when we contemplate the workings of our brains: Oh, what a world of unseen visions and heard silences, this insubstantial country of the mind! What ineffable essences, these touchless rememberings and unshowable reveries! And the privacy of it all! A secret theater of speechless monologue and prevenient counsel, an invisible mansion of all moods, musings, and mysteries, an infinite resort of disappointments and discoveries. A whole kingdom where each of us reigns reclusively alone, questioning what we will, commanding what we can. A hidden hermitage where we may study out the troubled book of what we have done and yet may do. An introcosm that is more myself than anything I can find in a mirror. This consciousness that is my self of selves, that is everything, and yet nothing at all -- what is it? And where did it come from? And why? There is disagreement among anthropologists about which came first, the neocortex or the tool, and possible cause and effect relationships. But it seems clear that little of what we call abstract thought (understanding the use of tools, planning for future benefits of making tools, etc.) took place before the neocortex developed. An understanding of the shaping of that capacity we call abstract thought begins with visualizing how our brains evolved over four billion years, from one-celled organisms all the way to Homo Sapiens. It's a fascinating journey. And for those of us who hope to take (or fear taking) the further evolution of our brains into our own hands, this journey of discovery is more than fascinating, it is essential to an understanding of the risks and the promises of such an undertaking. ** PHOTO SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "Chimpanzee, Australopithicene, Homo Erectus, Homo Sapiens." ** Paul MacLean's theory of the triune brain (1,7) is based on studies of comparative neuroanatomy and behavior. It gives us a useful and insightful model of brain evolution (a beautiful discussion of this theory can be found in Carl Sagan's book, "Dragons of Eden" (2)). In this view of brain evolution, we imagine the brain evolving very much like the remodeling of a house. ** DIAGRAM SPACE ** ** CAPTION -- "(A) Lemur-like animal, (B) Tarsier-like animal, (C) Old World monkey, (D) Modern chimpanzee, (E) Australopithicine, (F) Homo Erectus, (G) Neanderthal man, (H) Cro-Magnon man." ** While newer and more useful wings are being built, the older sections are still used. Even after the new areas are finished, older structures are not demolished, but kept for storage or reworked for other uses. To abandon a functioning brain part before a new component is in place would be dangerous for the owner of the brain. And evolution has not gained renown for a flair at scrapping out obsolete body parts. All creatures on this planet have distinct areas of the brain that correspond to evolutionary development over the ages. The first complicated life forms were one-celled. After many hundreds of millions of years, these ancestors found out how to join with other one-celled creatures and form more elegant and synergistic life forms like polyps and squid-like things, finally evolving into fish with eyes and gills. At this more advanced stage of evolution we had a brain stem to control such complicated functions as breathing and a heart to transport oxygen and nutrients to the vast community of cells making up our bodies. Still today, as Homo Sapiens, we have a brain stem -- our neural chassis -- that controls these functions. As we evolved into amphibians that ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (28) could exist on the land as well as in the sea, we needed a more developed brain. But we did not discard the brain stem. Rather, we built a new wing onto our neural mansion: the reptilian complex. The primary parts of the brain involved here are the medulla, pons, and basal ganglia, which are nerve centers that help control activities such as walking, breathing, swallowing, and heart rate, and also act as primary conduits for messages between the brain and spinal cord (4,7). Evolutionarily, this is frequently referred to as the R-Complex. It gave us hard-wired instructions like, "If it moves, bite it." Also, as many scientists contend, this area of the brain may produce the "frustration-aggression" reflex, and the seat of much of our uncontrolled violence as a species (7). Our reptilian ancestors found "survival value" in cooperating with other members of the species. New behaviors such as social hierarchies and the blind following of leaders began to develop as a result of this new interaction among members of various species. The ritualistic and often "mindless" or "hard-wired" behavior associated with this ancient part of our brains still functions in our heads and gives rise to the "cold- blooded" parts of our nature. Emotions were not to come along until mammalhood. With our evolution into mammals, long before achieving primate status, we developed still another wing and levels on our neural mansion. As it lies above and borders the R-Complex, it is called the limbic (Latin for "border") system. This inner surface of both cerebral hemispheres includes the thalamus, hypothalamus, and amygdala (4,7)). Here stirred for the first time such "hot-blooded" mammalian characteristics as caring for our young, altruistic behavior, and love for others. Many psychophysiologists (7) hold that some instinctual behaviors, like aggression, stem from the amygdala rather than, or in addition to, the reptilian complex. About this time, we began work on Project Paleocortex (which we would later call our "old cortex"), and increased the number of wiring connections from our limbic system into this new and fascinating part of our brain. Some abstract thought and planning could now be found in our limbic system, but it was, and still is, very limited. When the idea popped into our pin heads to evolve into primates, through and beyond Australopithecines into Homo Erectus, we knew we would need larger brains. It was obvious. So we invented the neocortex with two hemispheres and gave it convolutions to expand our abilities even further. Finally we relinquished the safety of redundancy and added, in our left hemisphere, talents and abilities for language and verbal behavior which would complement those in our right brain and carry us through Homo Habilis all the way to Homo Sapiens. Today, our brains still have these three major areas in addition to the brain stem: (a) the reptilian complex; (b) the mammalian or limbic system, and; (c) the neocortex (1,4,7). The neocortex, which represents the majority of the volume of the human brain (2), is where language, science, and civilization dwell. We invented the neocortex to make available to ourselves such wonders as the Star Wars Trilogy, computer games, and suspension bridges made of diamond fibers. But we did not discard our earlier systems. Sometimes these are still useful. Other times, perhaps, their influence could be better done without. This view of the evolution of the human brain is by necessity, a greatly simplified picture. Paul MacLean, in referring to his Triune Brain Theory, points out that the human "reptilian brain" is incredibly more complex than the brain of any crocodile or snake. And, in like manner, our limbic system far surpasses any owned by a cat or a rat. It should not surprise us then, to find that most humans have thoughts and feelings and actions far more sophisticated than either a crocodile or a rat. The current human brain has great multiplicity of function. Many types of behavior are associated with specific areas of the brain. For example, language and speech are associated with Broca's area, which usually lies in the left frontal lobe of the neocortex, in front of the motor area, except in cases where the brain has compensated for damage to the left hemisphere by forming the Broca's area in the right frontal lobe. And housing the ability to discriminate between words and the concepts they represent, and to create and act according to analogs of reality (and therefore likely the spring from which our sense of identity bubbles) is Wernicke's area in the left temporal lobe. But not all functions and behaviors are quite so specialized (3). Frequently, one area of the brain suppresses or "rides herd" over other areas. The neocortex, where we analyze and plan, often holds our emotional and aggressive (limbic) or hard-wired ritualistic (reptilian) tendencies in check. In other individuals (and in other situations within the same individual) the neocortex is less successful in maintaining control. The diversity of opinions over global situations -- such as current hostilities in the Middle East -- is a good example of how this tug-of-war between competing factors within the human brain contributes to such diversity of opinions over issues. A fascinating discussion of the vary- ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (29) ing hierarchies of agencies within the human mind (from a more philosophical, or perhaps one could say a computerized, mechanistic point of view rather than a neuroanatomical view) is Marvin Minsky's "The Society of Mind" (5). This is an enjoyable read while at the same time being a valuable contribution to an understanding of why we do the seemingly contradictory things we do. Another look at this subject, from still another point of view (this time from more of an anthropological angle) is that of Julian Jaynes, in "The Origin of Consciousness" in the "Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind" (8). Our reptilian tendencies toward ritualism make us fear change. Our leaders discourage change lest the "new order" oust them as leaders. The ever-present cultural lag experienced with new ideas, scientific discoveries, and the like is largely a manifestation of this primitive mandate to preserve the status quo. But in spite of some of this negative evolutionary baggage we carry around, the diversity of our brains gives us a richness of texture and a sense of individuality we all treasure and jealously guard. A graphic and dramatic analogy in a recent issue of Scientific American (6) helps us to visualize how the complexity of our neural structures paints for us our conception of our own individuality. "To grasp the beauty in a choral piece, it is not enough to listen to the individual singers sequentially. One must hear the performers together, as they modulate their voices and timing in response to one another." It is this three-layered (triune) brain with all its complexity (in the neighborhood of ten billion neurons (4), about twice the current population of planet Earth) that conjures up our warm and fuzzy feelings that we are more than just a mappable, reproducible pattern of information; that merely reading out the neuronal structures would almost certainly leave uncaptured some essential, elusive element of our identity and personality. It is not difficult to see the neocortex as a geographically ordered and transplantable pattern of information. We relate to this part of our brain as the "thinking part." Information structures fit. However, when we come to the emotions of our limbic system or the hard-wired instincts of our reptilian complex, this correlation is more difficult to assimilate. We reject these ideas on a "gut feel" level. Continuity of consciousness is the key to comfort for most who contemplate evolving beyond short-lived biological inhabitants of this small backwater solar system. We are all aware of the changes that our current medical sciences can make in our body and our mind. But we accept these with equanimity because the continuity of our consciousness is not threatened. When we wear eyeglasses or submit to heart-lung surgery, are we not altering our bodies and with them our identities? Yes, but we do not feel that continuity of consciousness has been interrupted. When a physician applies artificial life support systems to save the life of a child who might have died of sleep apnea, the brain stem has, in effect, been replaced, at least in part, with machines. Has that child lost its identity? We say "no" because, after all, it was only the brain stem! The child's continuity of consciousness and memory assimilation were not interrupted, at least no more then is usually experienced under anesthesia, which is typically acknowledged as irrelevant. Even today, we alter our brains' functional states of consciousness in more dramatic ways without any objectionable loss of identity continuity. This is commonplace. Today's physiological psychiatry routinely uses pharmaceuticals to modify behavior. For example, many forms of depression and mania are treated by potentiating neurotransmitters with drugs to increase levels of norepinephrine and treat depression or to increase serotonin availability in the brain and decrease anxiety (4,7). Do we say that people taking these drugs lose their identities because they are no longer plagued with depression or anxiety? Even those who admit that we have altered consciousness in such individuals seldom advocate that the sufferers be returned to their original states. The sufferers themselves, interviewed after treatment, report loss of fears, feelings of vastly increased stability, higher levels of self-control, and magnified mental capacities. Have these people become non-entities because of this drug intervention? Or would it not be more proper to say that they have willingly augmented their identities in extraordinarily positive ways? These drugs are altering the limbic system of our brains. If we can, even with today's technologies, alter our emotions, then we should feel no discomfort at the idea that emotional states will be even easier to produce and reproduce in the future. What of the question of mapping and reading out our brains into other vehicles of more ability and durability than the frail biological forms we inhabit today? Uploading, or moving data from a smaller computer to one with greater processing capabilities, is a term and a concept becoming popular within the high-tech life extension subculture. But not everyone feels comfortable with the idea of uploading her/his mind into computers or other bodily vehicles. We can take comfort in the knowledge that every aspect of our cosmos runs by the same laws. And, correspondingly, the neocortex was not built using laws of physics different from those which apply to the rest of the brain's structures. We evolved as carbon-based units on a given world with a given set of Tinkertoy parts. Our brains -- all parts thereof -- are bio- ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (30) logical electro-chemical machines. All parts, although evolved for different functions, obey the same rules of manufacture and management. This means when we acquire the technological sophistication (through nanotechnology or other means) needed to map the neocortex with its information and association areas, we will have the ability to map the limbic and the R-complex as readily. All the elements that make us up -- the good along with the bad -- can be preserved or mapped or uploaded equally well: the neocortex with its thinking and planning, the limbic system with its emotional responses, and the R-Complex with its hard-wiring. An understanding of the way our brain evolved comforts us with the knowledge that our mind is a symphony of neuronal interactions capable of being replicated in all its splendor. Understanding this, we become more comfortable with that elusive thing we call "identity." That fleeting wisp, the loss of which stirs disquiet in the hearts of so many who seek extended lives. That "I-word" which causes extreme discomfort and immediate rejection for many who consider uploading. Reflecting on the evolution of the human brain over the last several hundred million years strengthens our understanding of the prospects for transforming ourselves into beings housed in less vulnerable bodies, as well as the prospects for improving our information processing speeds and expanding our capabilities for joy, pleasure, and fulfillment. As we take evolution into our own hands, we become the conductors. We create neural symphonies to suit our own purposes. REFERENCES: (1) MacLean, P. "The Triune Brain, Emotion, and Scientific Bias". In The Neurosciences Second Study Program, edited by F.O. Schmitt. New York: The Rockefeller University Press, 1970. (2) Sagan, C. Dragons of Eden. New York: Ballantine Books, 1977. (3) Nauta, W.J.H., and Feirtag, M., Fundamentals of Neuroanatomy. New York: Freeman and Company, 1986. (4) Plotnik, R., and Mollenauer, S., Brain and Behavior, San Francisco: Canfield Press, 1978. (5) Minsky, M. Society of Mind, New York: Simon and Schuster, 1985. (6) Freeman, W.J., "The Physiology of Perception", Scientific American (February, 1991), pp. 78-85. (7) McConnell, J.V., Understanding Human Behavior, New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, 1986. (8) Jaynes, Julian. The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind, Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1976. Alcor News Executive Life: Damage Assessment Now that the smoke is starting to clear after the cave-in of Executive Life, damage assessments are becoming available. One projection made by an actuary for the firm of Coopers and Lybrand indicates that if all goes well, policyholders could expect between 71 cents and 74 cents on the dollar. Unfortunately, it's not that simple. Unless all the claimants cooperate, Executive may face liquidation, in which case California bankruptcy laws would come into play. The problem is that these statutes provide for 100 cents on the dollar for top claimants -- and little or nothing for those further back in queue. Currently Executive is in conservatorship. It is thought that with careful management and a change in the position of the IRS -- which is currently demanding $650 million from Executive -- the company might be salvageable. The question is, can everyone cooperate long enough to pull it off? And more to the point, can California's insurance bureaucrats (who have demonstrated a consistent history of total ineptness) "manage" the rehabilitation and sale? The California Insurance Commission reports that negotiations for the purchase of Executive Life by the French financial giant Credit Lyonnaise are nearing a successful completion. They also claim that if that deal falls through, there are two other buyers waiting in the wings. Media Attention Continues On 7 June the syndicated news-magazine show Hard Copy did a nine-minute piece on cryonics with the focus on Thomas Donaldson's efforts to gain permission to enter suspension before a brain tumor destroys his mind. This show is one of the most positive we've seen so far. It gets three stars out of four! Upcoming media coverage of cryonics and Alcor: Wall Street Journal TV is doing a short segment on Alcor and the "business angle" to cryonics. We don't yet know when this will air, but chances are it will be soon. The BBC's "Short Circuit" program which is targeted to the teen-age educational market also has a program in the works, as does HBO. We'll give you more details on these as they become available. The forthcoming Castlerock movie "Late For Dinner," which has a cryonics theme, is now scheduled for release late in the summer, possibly by late July or August. Also, the "48 Hours" episode that contains a segment about Alcor just re-ran, after having opened their fall season last year. Progress Is Good In Australia Progress continues to be made in the land down under. This group shows a lot of promise: consistently putting out a good top-flight local newsletter and continuing to meet deadlines set and deal with issues in a realistic fashion. The group has been holding independent training sessions and one of our correspondents tells us that these are being conducted professionally and competently. In the Alcor Abroad section of the September issue we will reproduce from their newsletter a horrifying little piece by Cath Woof on her encounter with the Coroner of New South Wales. And we thought we had problems -- this guy makes Ray Carillo look like Mother Goose. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (31) Cryonics is. . . The application of low-temperature preservation technology to terminal patients today is called cryonic suspension. The goal of cryonic suspension and the technology of cryonics is the transport of today's terminal patients to a time in the future when cell/tissue repair technology is available, and restoration to full function and health is possible -- a time when freezing damage is a fully reversible injury and cures exist for virtually all of today's diseases, including aging. As human knowledge and medical technology continue to expand in scope, people who would incorrectly be considered dead by today's medicine will commonly be restored to life and health. This coming control over living systems should allow us to fabricate new organisms and sub-cell-sized devices for repair and resuscitation of patients who will have been waiting in cryonic suspension. Alcor is. . . The Alcor Life Extension Foundation is a non-profit tax-exempt scientific and educational organization. Alcor currently has 17 members in cryonic suspension, hundreds of Suspension Members -- people who have arrangements to be suspended -- and hundreds more in the process of becoming Suspension Members. Our Emergency Response capability includes equipment and trained technicians in New York, Canada, Indiana, and Northern California, with a cool-down and perfusion facility in Florida. The Alcor facility, located in Southern California, includes a full- time staff with employees present 24 hours a day. The facility also has a fully equipped and operational research laboratory, an ambulance for local response, an operating room and a patient storage facility consisting of several stainless steel, state-of-the-art storage vessels. All Alcor board members, officials, and suspension team personnel are required to be full suspension members. Call toll-free (800) 367-2228 or write (see reverse for address) for the free book Cryonics: Reaching for Tomorrow. Table of Charges and Dues Sign-up Package: $300 first member of household, $150 each additional member. Whole Body Suspension Minimum: $120,000. Neurosuspension Minimum: $41,000. Outside U.S. Surcharge: $10,000. Annual Adult Dues: $252.00 Additional Adult Family Member Annual Dues: $126.00. Additional Family Member Child's Dues (under 15 years of age): 63.00 Adult Student Annual Dues (must be full time students): $126.00 You can tour the Alcor facility in Riverside, California under the expert guidance of the Alcor staff. The facility is open to small groups (15 people or less) who wish to learn how terminal patients are placed into suspension and how they are cared for at -320F. The Alcor tour also features a discussion of the scientific evidence that patients in cryonic suspension have a realistic chance of being restored to life, health, and youthful vigor as well as a fascinating exploration of the advances likely to come in the 21st century and beyond. The tour provides an invaluable opportunity for you to have your questions about cryonics and the prospect of an extended human lifespan answered. The Alcor tour is free of charge. If you'd like to make arrangements, call (800) 367-2228. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (32) ** TYPIST'S NOTE: THIS PAGE CONTAINED AN ORDER FORM FOR VARIOUS ALCOR ITEMS, BACK ISSUES OF CRYONICS, BOOKS, ETC. ** ---------------------------------------------------------------------- (33) ADVERTISEMENTS AND PERSONALS The Alcor Life Extension Foundation and Cryonics reserve the right to accept, reject, or edit ads at our own discretion, and assume no responsibility for their content or the consequences of answering these advertisements. The rate is $8.00 per line per month (our lines are 66 columns wide). Tip-in rates per sheet are $90 (already printed and folded); or $180 (printed one side) or $270 (printed both sides), from camera-ready copy. Tip-in advertisements must be clearly identified as such. WANTED: Panelists for a discussion of cryonics and life extension at the Chicon World SF Convention, Labor Day weekend (31 Aug - 2 Sept). Technical qualifications would be a plus. Contact Brett Bellmore; 8750 Burt Rd.; Capac, MI 48014; Tel: (313) 724-1293. MARY NAPLES, CLU and BOB GILMORE -- CRYONICS INSURANCE SPECIALISTS. New York Life Insurance Company; 4600 Bohannon Drive, Suite 100; Menlo Park, CA 94025. (800) 621-6677. EXTROPY: The Journal of Transhumanist Thought, #7. Memetics and cryonics, privately produced law, spontaneous orders (markets, agoristic computing, hypertext) neurocomputation, neologisms, transhumanism, reviews of Smart Drugs, and more. $4 from Max More; P.O. Box 77243, Los Angeles, CA 90007- 0243 MEETING SCHEDULES Alcor business meetings are usually held on the first Sunday of the month. Guests are welcome. Unless otherwise noted, meetings start at 1 PM. For meeting directions, or if you get lost, call Alcor at (714) 736- 1703 and page the technician on call. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- The AUGUST meeting will be at the home of: (SUN, 4 AUG 1991) Bill and Maggie Seidel 10627 Youngworth Rd. Culver City, CA Directions: Take the San Diego (405) Freeway to Culver City. Get off at the Jefferson Blvd. offramp, heading east (toward Culver City). Go straight across the intersection of Jefferson Blvd. and Sepulveda Blvd. onto Playa St. Go up Playa to Overland. Go left on Overland up to Flaxton St. Go right on Flaxton, which will cross Drakewood and turn into Youngworth Rd. 10627 is on the right (downhill) side of the street. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- The SEPTEMBER meeting will be held at the home of: (SUN, 1 SEP 1991) Marce & Walt Johnson 8081 Yorktown Avenue Huntington Beach, CA Directions: Take the San Diego Freeway (Interstate 405) to Beach Blvd. (Hwy 39) in Huntington Beach. Go south on Beach Blvd. approximately 4-5 miles to Yorktown Ave. Turn east (left) on Yorktown. 8081 is less than one block east, on the left (north) side of the street. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- * * * There is an Alcor chapter in the San Francisco Bay area. Its members are aggressively pursuing an improved rescue and suspension capability in that area. Meetings are generally held on the second Sunday of the month, at 4 PM, followed by a potluck. Meeting locations can be obtained by calling the chapter's Secretary, Carol Shaw, at (408) 730-5224. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- The AUGUST meeting will be held at the home of: (SUN, 11 AUG 1991) Keith Henson and Arel Lucas 1794 Cardel Way San Jose, CA Directions: Take the 17 South (880) and get off going east on Camden. Stay on Camden as it turns south and go to Michon Dr. Turn right onto Michon and go to Harwood Rd. Turn left on Harwood and go south to Almaden Rd. (1st street on right). Turn right on Almaden and right again onto Elrose, then left onto Cardel. 1794 is near the end of the street, on the left. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- The SEPTEMBER meeting will be held at the home of: (SUN, 8 SEP, 1991) Leonard Zubkoff 3078 Sulphur Spring Court San Jose, CA ---------------------------------------------------------------------- * * * There are two Alcor discussion groups in the Greater New York area. Details may be obtained by calling either: Gerard Arthus, at (516) 474-2949, or Curtis Henderson, at (516) 589-4256 The New York Cryonics Discussion Group of Alcor meets on the third Sunday of each month at 2:30 PM, at 72nd Street Studios. The address is 131 West 72nd Street (New York), between Columbus and Broadway. Ask for the Alcor group. Subway stop: 72nd Street, on the 1, 2, or 3 trains. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- The meeting dates are as follows: AUGUST 18 SEPTEMBER 15 OCTOBER 20 NOVEMBER 17 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- The Long Island Cryonics Discussion Group of Alcor meets on the first Saturday of every month, at the home of Gerry Arthus. The address is: 10 Jefferson Blvd.; Port Jefferson Station, L.I., telephone (516) 474-2949. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- The meeting dates are as follows: AUGUST 3 SEPTEMBER 7 OCTOBER 5 NOVEMBER 2 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- * * * There is a cryonics discussion group in the Boston area meeting every second Sunday at 3:00 PM. Information may be obtained by contacting Eric Klien at (508) 663-5480 (work) or (508) 670-5235 (home). There will be a meeting August 11 at 3 PM at the home of Eric Klien; 28 Kenmar Dr., #272; Billerica, MA 01821. Take the 3 north to the Concord exit, and go right toward Billerica. The fifth street on the right is Kenmar. Go to the driveway one short of the end of Kenmar and turn left. Go to Building 28 (last building). * * * The Houston area has a discussion group on cryonics, life extension, and the high/low diet. Meetings are typically held the second Saturday of every month. For more information call Ravin Jain at 713-797-1076 or Rupert Hazle at 713-480-3309. Correspondence may be addressed to Rupert Hazle at 15107 McConn, Webster, TX 77598. Other Events Of Interest There will be an Alcor fund-raising dinner on Saturday, September 28 at 7 PM at the LAX Marriott Hotel, 5855 W. Century Blvd., Los Angeles. The goal is to raise money to continue Alcor's research to improve cryonic suspension services. Reports will be given on recent advances in cryonic suspension, ongoing research in cryonics, and plans for future research. Reservations are $100/plate, check or money order to Alcor at 12327 Doherty St., Riverside, CA 92503; or by credit card to 1-800-367-2228. HoMEҹͳƵ ENTER NUMBET 0020
115 ձٶ ٺ ԭӻ޷ ŷŸ ˽Ѩ 衡阳市有喲׬帮男Є足交的女的 ɫ ôɶ˲ٹ ɫ WWW.756NN.COM WWW.LYCYJXX.COM WWW.RQFWJ.COM WWW.BB5278.COM WWW.MYXIGUA.COM WWW.83DDCC.COM WWW.NBSESE1.COM WWW.DAILYNK.COM WWW.470F.COM WWW.COCOD1.COM WWW.DGRTAV.COM WWW.0755MSX.NET WWW.92ITT.COM WWW.AIMSEN.COM WWW.TIENV.COM WWW.DUOXXDUO.COM WWW.JNYSHS.COM WWW.477BO.COM WWW.LIFAN2.COM WWW.TAOPIC.COM WWW.72JEE.COM WWW.CCC566.COM WWW.BBB900.COM WWW.MU444.COM WWW.998QQ.COM WWW.SG50.COM WWW.DY238.COM WWW.TYQZJX.COM WWW.BBB092.COM WWW.HHH421.COM WWW.25JO.COM WWW.CGXIA.COM WWW.423U.COM WWW.CCC973.COM WWW.BBB960.COM WWW.YUFUHS.COM WWW.YQHI.COM WWW.975XX.COM WWW.82293.COM WWW.55TUAN.COM WWW.PPZHIBO.COM WWW.4OYE.COM WWW.452F.COM WWW.13NVNV.COM WWW.44WQ.COM WWW.AV54321.COM WWW.AA191.COM WWW.XYDXTB.COM WWW.SEAVIRI.COM WWW.0915CC.COM WWW.BTLHJ.COM WWW.98FN.COM WWW.65JM.COM WWW.SHBTBY.COM ¼gdgd ϱϵ AAAŷ޽ ݳѻɫƬ www520520eme wwwbbs8haokancn ɫи԰ ̳ Ʒ˿̬av347yycom avɧɫƵ h Ƶۺַ Ʋ 켤ͼƬ gav޲ѹۿ ͼƬ͵Զ ˳ ŷȺͼƬ wwwbu510com av ߸Ь򽺸߸Ь xb98090 avҹžžžž ˰׻ www777eycom ֻ߿˵Ӱav luɹ QVOD2017 www611hhhcom ҹҹŮ avӰkan212comwwwkan212com Ŷij ɫ ȫĸϵС˵ ƬƵ ɫͼ myoujizzcominfo ҹɫ ̬ͼƬ ߣ³³ www aaa776 com ѹƵ ٸŮ15 ܿavվ ݺݸwww92eeeecom ͹ λɧŮͼƬ ɫ߿ ŮԽƵ Сɫɫ 鶼ۺ պŷ Ì椳 ַͬѧwwwssmm5com wwhxhxmagnet www2325con ֣ݻ޾ֲ͵ kk3343magnet ͼƬ ӰȷǿӰƬ һƬ 85422com 144ͼƬ ߵӰѡԺ ˳Ƶ ɫӰԺ ŮͼƬ www155hucm ֲӰԺ ŷŮ˱ƱƱ ʲô⿴Ƶ Ůο߹ۿ ϼ av߹ۿ ˮƵ ʢƬ Ůַ ձwwwվ ҷѨȷ СƵ 7777kjcomֱ avҹŷҹ糡 wwwkkkk25 wwwun7 ٸŮ50p AVɫ ԱɽŮ ݺߣ㽻 ӰӰ avav ɫav wwwwxxx520av ŰҪ ¶ֻ С˵شү wwwwnnn92com ɱ12p ԰ŷɫͼ ɫӰȷԴ ŮձӰӰȷ պac ȥҲ ŵѧ˺öˮ Ů߹ۿ aƬ ÿƬAƬ ÷ƿ ĸČ ҳ 97οƵ a avվ߹ۿ ԰avɫͼav ĸɫС˵ СŮ ŷƨƵXXX ʿĸwwwmcc676com þòܳ 66齻 77v1ֻƬ ø°ҩȫ magnet 8vaaсом ͩж ӱ ٸջƵ mumuĻɫվ ˶www42nscom ۺ Űĸmagnet ɫɫmp4 ͵İٶȰٶ ҰԽӰ tsubomiС ͬѧҳ߹ۿ ŷ԰Ѩɫͼ av12ֱ 37pao?co?m Ʒ˿avӰȷ ˿ͼƬheshizfucom Ƭ첥ۿmtvqvodcom һɫӰԽƬ žžav vaӰƬ ɫɫ94ŷsetu94laxcom ۺɫվ ͯɫӰѹۿ ͬ·ҴսС˵ ͵ ˹Խַ 㶮zoos ҰսƬ sm ׻ ӰԺ Ƶ Www ˭гվ űֲĺˬ þճAV Ůʦ BʮVɶ˼ ձƵmagnet vvvv900 www4k4com 㽶ĺվ avƷƵַ ͵߹ dizhi99ÿ ɫߣƬ ԰ ϼavmqiuxia6com ߣ ŷavۺ ӰԺ ɫ msusu77com ˿͵ֻƵ ͲֶŮɧ վ º Ůɧ ɧɩӰԺɾ ű Ů׽͵ йӰ ձŮٱο ձ˿Ӱ Ů ̫һ ˽ڵͼƬ aʳѵӰ ŷٸ͹ͼ ߠ忧人体艺术 ѵӰ׽ͬ־ Ѩˮ ǿУ԰Ůʦ Ӱȷ70̫̫ ձӰַ Ӣ ձŮavĸ WWW_GBGB123_COM ϲŮ Ƭձ Ƶ Ұ±Žĩ ye321Ӱȷ ɫavͼƬ Ļ Ů츾 ԼСӰȷ ѧСҪ ɧѨĴ ӰҰŮ ŮԻͼƬ Сǰ С ϵƷͼƬ Ӻϱ 迴ξ ļ218 ԾյӰȫ155 ģ˽ Ű ҺĸԭƬ ̾ 660avcm mmұ ɽ֮ĸ youzz Լ Ļɫ ԾյӰ ҪavӰ ձ ɧ ׻ɧ 첥׵Ӱ ӰԱ ͵ŮՌͼƬ ӱloudian ̬ͼ к ׼ͥĸС˵ ̵ĵӰ ݺ͵ۺ Ůbͼ 첥 ũ׼һַ żƱ ݻƱƱ绰 ̩֤ȯ ѵγ ݴբз konicaminolta ʮʹͽ ɧŮh ̫̫ڻ Ӱ ŮͬѧƨͼƬ ʮ2014ȥؿµַ Ѩͼ ڃqvod첥 δд 첥͵Ƭ ůƵ ޼ louyinbuŮƬ ߣһߣɫм˿ ձһͼƬ WWWUUKKMCOM 첥Խ ձʿͷд ef29c71b0000b444 ԱС˵ ŷֻ ݿ˴̷Ůͼ ŷԸ˿ŮɫŮͼƬ Ů ˶СƵ ֻӰԺӰ2017 ñͼ ƬavƬ 51av½ ȱ߹ۿ avС С˵޻ͼƬ һɫͼƬ 163com ɫɫͼɫɫ ɫͼӰԺ ۺͼ ׾ŮӾ ޳˵һվ ͵ùϴ йŮͼ ŷʮ qianjgjianluanlunzaixianshipin С˵ů ӰԺϢ ɫͼƬ ۺͼɫһͼƬ ԼϵƵȫ ߹ۿɫɫӰԺ貥 첥Ӱô С˵ ӱe2k ɺ ɫ۹ֻ ˧ʮ״󼦰Ͳƨ Сɫbi 첥Ӱɫ Ƶжg ɫ ŷͼ ɫþŰ֥ ŮͼƬչ WWWSSSCCCLLLCOM 8080av ͥײٱ һģ wwwqingjunlumagnet Ů˱յͼƬ wwwɫqqcom ˾ɩɩС˵ ٶȫͼƬ ⼫ƷŮ ɫվ Ůɫ www96iseinf ֶĻ ɫ첥ַ wwwzzzbbbbcom ſһ m1905ֻӰ wwwþòĻ ѹۿһձëƬ ʯھ޲jpxieavcom ɫͼ˿ɹ ԺһɫԺ ʽʦϩ`ɺڥ 4p¶ wwwyda3info ŮƵѲžžٶȰٶ ȫּŮ ɫӰ26uuu 9czxkan ־ӢɯаͼƬ ɫXXXٶ ˵ juse Ů԰ϵ AVСӹۿ ¥ǿŮӰԺ С˵ŷͼƬͼƬ ĸԽƵwap17nnnncom 123ٱưٶ wwwavСձվ ˿Ʒ ȫŮ ǿxС ֻþÿӰ ɫƬëƬƬҳ ձŮxxx 777sejingwang ŷٺ www·mumu98·commp4 ԰ַ 16ŮJIZZ ŷ԰Ӱ ŷѨˬƬ avŮ Ʒ ݸƴƨ wwwdiyesao ŮԾ ŮԱԸС˵ Թ¹ ͵ͼƬȫ žžͼҵƵ ëɦջ Ҵmagnet ͵ĴǶ 81xacom С ޳˿첥Ӱwww080xxcom С˵ Ѱɫ12 ӣǵӰ ˭ֻ www.vip.shop wwwСcn n187 Ů Ϊʲôɫ 첥Ƭ ŮƬ ܿɫС˵վ wwwɫС˵ ĵĻ԰ Ů˷ ӰԺ 99ɫӰ ɫӰԺ ͥAV ɫɫ ʦӰ ܰ ˸ɫAƬ ɫü ܻ԰̳ ԰Ƭ 009hhۺ ɫӰԺ ۺ ߣ Ҳߣ ߣһ ɫ絼 ɫ ѧhĶ ӰHվ ޡx ɴ456 ʤ侸 ߲ŵһ ʦaƬ ۺϽۺ ۺͼƬɫ͵ ʼLu23 ˮƵ jlzzjlzzڲ Ψ ȫ4438x ȫŮƵ ԸŮ˿ȹӰʱ˵ˬ˵ ҵҪ糱 ޹ СѧŮʪӰԺ аeڹڵ3d ԽŮ ߹ƵƷƵ ձƵһ߲ ӣԴ߹ۿ ձһӰeeuss ձŮɫ͸Ƶ ӰȷձӰƬ ӰȷԴվ ɫhdƵ ľӰӰƬİ vip ٱƴƬ ӰԺƬ Ŷ԰ ĹӰζhƬ߿ Ϻֵ˫ ֻĸƵ Ұɱb߹ۿ Ůο ƵƵ jizzzzz meyd165ЭӰ İ ձƬ ȥҲAv AV˹ ֻ̬AV japanese girl voise 㽶Դ òݸ ׿ ƷƬ ӰȷAVӳ btshare СѧŮƵ ǿƵ pppd-711Ѹ ϼ˾糡һdvd ձһƵ ɫŮɫŮӰԺ ѧŮƵ Ӱ ľ һҹƬ øվ 㶮վ߹ۿAV ԰P v ˴ҹѸ ڿaëƬ~ Ȳȹ 921000߲ 10Ѩ 㽶avè ¥78Ӱ ýۺվ ŷxo ı6pƵ ʬ̷2ֻ ȷAVվ ּ ed2k Ļ wwwffff888con AVƬ ed2k ɰ﷬߹ۿ ߲ ww8o6oƬ ŷAv3dվ ¥Уmp4 һ߿һο ɫվ88888888 woailan ѧaƬ С21Sž ˼۲av Ӱav ջxfplay pu370ַ ŷAVͨ Ѳվ AvƵ ֻ Ծ 26uuu캣 ľ δɫɫ julia Ӱ miniĦɫһƬ ޳avƬ߹ۿ߶ ɫվ 㽶 ԭ H߿ ŮּƵ yy4480ձƬƵ ŮŰƵ ŮƵ xxoo ɯ xx4s4scc 97zyԴվ߿ saobulu Ƶ㶮 ϼ ɫ㽶 ŷƵ pֻƵ Ƥ ӰԺ4k xCart̷Ѹ ϵ˿ www4455dpcom ԭ糡 Ƭƽ̨ ޳Ƶ 1024Ůο СӰԺ1240Ƶ ҹҹƵѿ պӰŷ 538߾ƷѰ˹ 91Ƶ ˵Ӱ͵ ڱƵ69 Ļ պ Ÿ Ƭ Ѹ avۿվ ɫɫԴվ ftp 538ڳƵ߹ۿ aԱƵۿ ھưɱڹҩ ¿ƵӰԺ ̷ͮ Ƶ ԴƵ ʥƵ 4123 2018 av bѩ ŷbƵ 㽶ƵƵӰԺ ڵƵ ӰͬƬƵԴ j8aa52 ˮ䷿ ɫƵС˵վ Ѹ״ Ӱȷ氢̲Լ ԺavƵ ɫľþò߹ۿ xfplay캣 Э ΢ƵСӰ avɫá wwwsexiu94 ݲ ɫɫɫ U07ԸȺ rctC493 ŷͼ бƵ þƵ ڲſڱ̾Ů ޱԴ ɧ Сٸ͵Ƶ ɳƵȫ ССҰAv ѧջϼ magnet ȷɫɫ˵Ӱ ˿ɫɫС˵ ɫɫƵ ȷӰdz а acg﷬ȫ3d ձѧ侫 4438ȫƵ ĸСƵ japaneseĻ 91߿ ǿӰ wwwd111mɫ ˲ٲ · ɱѹƵ У԰ɫŷƵ Ѩʪ ձʪӰԺ ˿̨apk Ƭ߲ У԰͵СŮƵ Ƶ߹ۿ й԰Ƶѹۿ Ƶ mp4 ձͼݱǿ ѹɫ¿Ƶ kanav߹ۿ 52s 캣 ū ŷAƬӰԺ ٸ͵ƵͼƬ Ӱվլլÿ AV Ӱ ͵һվ 111 СñAV߹ۿ xoo430 ˵ϸɫ a߹ avֻ 궡 ac Ұ2018 ͵ֱ Ƶ ӰԺеĻɫƵ ҹ ټѰ ӰӺкݺ ¶ Ұ ftp 鴲ϴ߶Ƶ ϼeee ͼƬ ͵aйƵ ҪֵͿԿAV vvӰ Ұּ߲ TGGP78߹ۿ ˿ҡӰƵ 侫 ŮƵֻƵ Ƶɫͼ Ůbֱƽ̨ Ƶ ſڽ h ɫÿɫۺ ʪƵ 128 Ƭ 㽶 žžƵ ݮ100Ƶ Ƶ ˰Ӱ߲ Ӱȷ ŮƵ Сƹ Ůžž1000Ƶ þav ˿صavŮ ˮѸ ed2k ˵ŮƵ ٱƵ Ů25p ʿƷ رʵս˿Ʒ pƵ ձŮ magnet Ůͬ ҹɲ õӰպԽƵ ɯlisaLU ձ ĿսƬѸ ҹֱƵ ɫӰԺͼƬӰԺ žž߲ ɫ߸ ҹɫɫӰԺJ ԿѨƵ tľӰ ͵_3ҳ_av 787ӰԺҹ ذٶ camporn ֳ ձ IJˮƵ ɫ ¶žžŮƵ2վ èav㽶Ƶ ɫɫ ¶ ߳ӰԺapp ٱƵ Ƶ ֱο ͥԽƵ Ӱаagcа ͌ ǿ鸣СƵ߹ۿ ͬžžžƵ 4438xx5 Ӱ պ԰첥 ޸ av㽶ӰԺ www,caoborn,com ܱ쳯 ڹTawtawе ﲼ˴mag AMSRٶƵ ӰԺ ʯδٶ Ů侫Ƶֱ ľrio ӰԺ hlwnds88 ҹӰԺ ŮʦƵۿ ɫ·ַ Ů³³̬Ƶ ˿Ӱ Ƭ? ˿Ůο ɫƵŮֱο magnet k8fldh 㽶 ɫСƵ ŷٶ ߸ƬƵվ ͼƬ Ʒ űaƬ ޹ 141tube ʦаӰԺa պ첥Ժ 456Ӱ˾߹ۿƷ AVӰ zipaisipai ŷenen ŷ˿Ů magnet ˳Ƶ Ůܳ ̫aƵ ޸Ƶ Ƶ mp4 ɫӰԺ ôҪŰ߳ ٸ ѧ ŮƵ2018 ˲Ůdd ɰͷСɧŮ칫С¶ĵ ߸ ɫ߲Ƶ ͵Ƶվ 1ƬƵ غ͹ magnet yunfileӰƬ Ƭ žžžžȫ ƵС˵Ӱ ˸Ӱֻլլ AVͬ ɮཻɫ ʦ޸Ķav ՌŒ ѵӰһ ƵƵ ĸϼ sanjiƵֱ 㽶Ƶ Ƶ3681 ͥС˵ ô Ůͼ ջԽɾ ? Ӱȷav ƵͼƬ ˲Ů˵ĶƵ Ӱȷּѧ԰ħ޵ľ޴ַ ҲɫƵ Ůʲô aƬ߿ ˹д 91pomƵվ IJƵ ĸϷʱСIJ ¿ôѻ ŷ ̩Ů԰ͼƬ Ӱpoco ޿ ҵĶ˹ Ʒ׸15p ¶ͼ Ǫд avsedyٶӰ ŮŮд ձmm Ӹͼ ģ¶д ŷŰӰַ ٳйصĵӾ 99Ů Ƶ дŮֳд ¶ë ͵޽ɾ ɧ Ըŷ˧ պȭͷƿ첥 ¶ em6666com ŷ˰ ݺ³ ˵ɧbͼ ŷڽٱ ձͼpian WWW_05SUSU_COM setu38p ˌ ij˾쵼Լ90Ūݸ ɧ ٱС ѨС˵ ͼ ɽ˲ ׸ʦͺѧ ľС˵ŷ С ɫ ŮȵǿС˵ ˵ļͱȶĻ · ů԰ ԰Ƶ ɫС˵׹ ߣߣиϵ 10ŮČʲô 2973 ŷƬbt Ӱ ձƵ mmͼ 첥ַ̼ ԺͼƬ ٸ30p ձд Ƶ͵ŮԽƵ Ծbt ´󺺲ٱͼ ۺ ŮС ͬԽƬ ģjiaojiao ɧ wҪݱ 444ɫ ŮԽͼƬ WWW_88BBU_COM ʦ԰ͼƬ Č HͼƬ Ů©ͼƬ ϱ 266uuu26uuu ҹҵİ ŮԵƬ ư Ұɽô hd598 ȫ 812 ȰDZͼ Һ԰ ɧٸСɫũôͼƬ ͵¶ 69ɫɫͼ Ľøֱ Ҫ ձ׻ ԿƬ˵Ӱ ·޽ һĵӰ ɫ 籲ϵsex Լͼ ŷͼ첥ӰƬ ٶŮǿƵ ouzhoujiqing3 ɬ ŷͼ ȫСѨŮͼƬ ձԸд󼦰 ٱƱ Ƭ Ƶ ƨɴӵav · 18Ӱ ٸѨ15 ķɫҳͼƬ ɫٱƬдzhen ɫɫ ҹٱͼƬͼƬ Ռºˬ Ů˺͹Խ 첥޼ŷ ۺɫ ɫҪv yazhousetu26p ͵긾Ůʵ ٶд ϳ̳ Ǯһ ͵ٶ ۴󼦰 ߣɫƵ ũ WWWXFYSLUBCOM Ϸ Ҹ19pͼƬ ͵b 㽻 ˽ӰԺܿʲôӰ ɫͼ ڲ Ƭ ŷ18p԰Ƶ ڰ칫Ҳɧ ԾմдͼƬ ˿ɧ ͵ܵܲٱ С ɫͼɫɫ ׯ պp Ů²Ƭ ŮдӰԺ 첥׵Ӱ ܵܲõĹ ŮСѨ ʮ·Ů ջӰwap78nucom еĺŮIJٱƵ ŵɧƱ cythereaƷ Ů16p ͼƬȫƬ¶ þոѧƵ Сӳձ ڼɶ ɫͼcosplay Č aiͼƬ ԾոƬ ľav www8se9se ˴ŮƵ WWWNV888COM ɫվ ʮŮѨ ͼ ʪѨô 478ddse Ƶxxx ٸҴ ɫϷ ѳƵַ 򵥿ѧТȫ ŮǸ弤ɫͼ ɫqingdianӰ Ů ŷ԰ͼһҳ ɧŮ Ժ ͼۺ ٸͼƬ Ů˿Ѩ xxuu33com ¶ ɫС˵ɫС Ů˱ͼƬ ͵xxxձؼƬxxxxձ zhangmuniangshipin SSVԴ ƷԮϵͼ AV޵Ӱ ǿ·С˵ wwwyoujiuzzcom ǻ 32saocom ٶȶϷ AV͵Ƶmbaiducom Сmp4 ೦ؽӰ 鷿ˮͼpain С˵ Сũ ˬ Ůɫ ɫӰƬؽ У԰ɫŵѨ רҵ Ů̫ɫ ɫͼ͵hd ۻɫӰ ǧ1991magnet ʮ붯 ͬѧɫӰ ձӰ 7788mp3 崦Ůʱʲôо ӱavԴ avwwwc5508com wwwcom ɫͼ ͵IJСѨ ձaƬǿĸ ջ߲ ɫƬƬ seԭַ ð йɧƱ ϲվ뽫swwwgg514com lol ݺԻݺݸwwwssav88com Ůѷվ ùݽдƵm56comvqqcommvqqcom ӰٶȻɫӰ ɫͼٶ ˽ڳ͵ٸ߹ۿ magnet tokyohot޼ 911ɫɫɫӰ 5xww1com5xww1com ɫAv ҰngƵmdyguocom ɫǶƬvideopaebaiducom youjizzлzz վӾװ Ϲ ½ëƬ԰ ɫwap54ixcom ߣ˳ wwwxbfe պѧƵѸ ɫwwwqqsp1com Ļ¥һ biantailinglei furendaչ 3d﷬߿ Ӱȷɫջ ְô ۺ wwwaznidmolgmcn ķɫ Ұɳ76 ŵ³ ˿ ed2k﹧ taiwan3jipian ԰鶼ɫͼ ΰ ˿ٱ ŷռ ɫ˸ɫС˵2 첥ǿqvwod qingse97 ·޲ٱ Ӱ͵ porn ˿ AVСձ ǺӴͬС˵ ͥ׳Ӱȷ www77kksscom ѧ ɫCCӰԺֻ ŷĶм wwwmeinvmei222 Ժ ŮlС˵ av ߳˶ ȫɫԴƵ òĻ ˻ɫС˵С˵վ ֻѹۿɬƵ첥 wwwwcon520XXid ͨһҳۺ ŮΪū Ů˽ͼƬ øվ ɫͼ12P 18avƵ حȳAV ˳Ƶ һavԴ ձĸǿ meiguose Ÿɫͼ Сɫɫ ŮڿοƵ ձavСƵ ؿζ̬1ҳ ȭƵ Ůʪ۵ⶴ ԰׹ľþ ձžžСӰ ɫ ͵Ƶ ͼƬ ұԸаooxx ˻ɫɫͼӰ ³С˵ ߹ۿŷͥ ߣ xiaoshuo 33mnbcomi 91ֻƵ ޸ëƬ СѨ ˵Ӱ_͵_ͼƬ_ŷͼƬ_ߵӰWWWAVAV91 ѧƵ ҲӰԺmagnet JAVHDftp dvdɫav Ƭձmagnet ϼС˵Ķ ٺ· ѹۿͬѧƵ ձսƵ ĻƵ Ļѻɫվ wwwgaoav 첥AV߹ۿƵ ӣƵۿ ؽ ĻƵavwww2pidcom aiseiwang ͵͵IJ ղԻԻߣ ıư ǰƵ ŮAvëƬ ֭50p ޡƵ wwwTv Ӱۿ ͼƬŷ͵ͼƬ seri123һվ WWW033secon ɫͷȫ ɫŮ ߣһߣŷɫͼٱ ͼƬƵ͵ŷͼƬ 960AAA һAV ްT ģ ޤνβӰȷ С͵Ƶ www54qqqcom 1138xwang AV av޶ WWW288hhcn žž ްĦ ԰ӰëƬ www789ɫ ɬӰapp ߣѸ׿ Ƭ236 mmӰ ͵ߣߣ СŮ ٸ ŮΪɫС˵ 236zzcon Ƶѹۿ ɫ 5b5b88com www76ҳ www5799com ҪǮAV ɫعɫعl ͵Ʒ˿У԰ɫ wwwff635con ԾյӰȫ xxǿƪ www590uucom Ů ɫվӰȷ Ψŷmagnet WwWr4747com seselululu ŮһƬ ձ ǿĸŮ ޵ҵܿ ּ ԽƵ Ů 81xacom ŷūav ŮԲƬŮ Ȼ¶ zoosexviedeo дmp4 ŮШĹ Ů˿ Сɧ ĻƵ߹ۿӰ redtuberedtubecomwwwredtubepl ɧŮοͼ dizhi99ձ츾 ȹƵ ӵİ 92359պɫŮƾӰ wwwhh99mocom ˭гվ phoenixmarieС ëʦ36D ԰ɫ ϼƬav Ӱȷ漱ȷ ɫƵ ŷԽվ ŷɫƬ߲ 5xƵѹۿ 228df һaƬվ Bߣ ɫɫ 6699mp4 ˿ɫͼȷ Ʒ˿С˵ֻ av96 AVɫ ŮѸ ޽Ůھ иջϵ ٿսɫͼ ŮͬĦϵС˵ ʯ鱨վȫtxt ʿɫ1234 ׻СѨ ŷƷѨ ϲŮ15p ŮѨgraphis ɫ޼ Ӱ 椺ľ Ծ¶ëͼƬ Ů Ӱ첥 HƬ ŷŮϷ ػɫƬ ̫̫ϴ ԻŮݲ ٸջӰȷ ŮԽͼ ֺڼͲɧͼ ƯԸ׻ ͵Ľ ed2k ŷŮ 3pƵ ũͼѧɫŮ ɧѨͼ ɫվһƵ Ů󰮸ؽp ڱ͵ ϱƲ16p ٸ˵ 첥ʿ ַŮʦ캣rmvb ͦС ͵Ůɫͼ Ű֥Ƭȫhuawei ŮuuӰ WWW_168200_COM ҰŮ˿btӰ ޱݲٱƴ Ҷ2ɧ Hжˬ 最名的性爱网站 Hū ɫն̬ vvvv888com 󼦰͵һƪ ŷŮڽ ŮĹ zi߿ ħ3˻ɫվ ԾյĵӰ ֭Һ ɫó˶ ŷŮ˿ڽ ³Ϧ Ұav첥 Ůؽ 2kkvv yin ͼƬ ½ Ҷ˴ Ѹģд ɫƬ17һ18Ů ׿첥 ͵˽Ȥ Ӱ ɫӰԺŮԽ txtȫ ǧ ÷ɹ˪ dzɸ Ů־ ӰƤ и ɧŮh ȷӰƷソ ͵Ů WWWSAO65COM ϳ԰ ΰС˵ɫ Ѵĸϵ ĸ ԺԺ㽶 վ ŮѨ www111Ůֳ С츾ʢtxtɾ ֻӰԺֻ ɫˬˡͼƬ òav Һͱ͵ ͵ŮοƵ 360jjj ɫƵѵ 첥ay ŷavԸд ޳ͼ ʦٌ ɫƬԽ С Ը˿Ůͼŷɫͼŷɫͼ ppp36ͼƬ ţţƵ ⲥ԰Ӱ Ů ƱͼƬ cup WWW23E3COM ÿĻС˵ ɳ Ӱȷ߹ۿ˵Ӱ duppid1duppid1 Сȫmp3 Œͼͼ ŷ ԾձŮǰ ŷӰ Ȥ˿ͼƬ ʥɧ øɵӰ С˵ۺԴ ɧСѨ ŮűּС˵ ŵĴƨɰ ʪ۷۱ ŮСͼƬ ŮɫѨ 㽭ĸʵ ŷٸɧԸ߳ ŷԸͼ ӰԺ Ů˵ˬˬ aƬ޲ Ұ21 dzվı avɫɫ ֥Ӱ д󼦼Ůȷ ͼƬŷͼձAvС˵ СƵ߹ۿwww51gannet ֪hentalvideo WWWQQMATOUCOM ɫŮqq ޱ ŮӰ bta18con ƵӰС˵ѿ spanking ǿӰ ˲ٳ˽г˸ 81h6699us ϴԡ˫ͨȫ lindaϵ ռav Ǻϳͼ ձվ fuliltˮ ƬƬëƬ ӰAVmagnet ŷɫŮ ˿Сѧַ ͵ɫŮ Ů۱ ҰԭζƵ ⻪av ŷɫӰ H΢ ԾյӰ Ĵڱ yy6080վͼƬ 15pÊ ڹѸɫС˵ ⲥ ձٹ ë һqvodȫ ҹɫּٸ ӰԺ Ƭ˭ 777sejingwang 𷻳С˵www68kqcom ͼƬŷͼƬպ ɫcon ĸŮ swww104sihucom ͵̳Ƶֱ ձʿο첥 xxxxxٱ www123bbbbɫӰ pҶ 5252avavavhaos01 òݶк Ҷ鲻Խqvod q2002ַ Ůvideopaebaiducom ͣsexĸƬ ҹ ŷƷʦ ŷAvͼƬ av߻ɫվ ԸŮ gir ɫɫ»ɫɫ av۵̨ С˵ͼƬ͵ĵӰ AV ʦ ڽ ŷHƵ ɫɫͼ ɫ µӣƬ С3 Сֽ СǺ Ӱh ˭µֻ www.ΨƷ ʶ ɫ 첥 qqռ俴Ƭ 5252ɫС˵ ȥɫɫ ֮ ٶɧ Ծ빷 ջɫۺ ü ҪӰ Ӱ Ұ̳ 007˵Ӱ ɧˬӰ se ߣһ mum002߲ ˬˬӰԺôƽ ɫ ĵķʽ߹ۿ ¶ۺϽƵ caopornҳ ߶ȴֱ 40ëƬ պҹ magnet wwwffff15con av gavⰲװ ƵֻƵİ˹ һӰԺ mp4 www,Fac158 avƵ Ⱥο magnet av Ӱ ɫɫev sw-167 ijչ˾սѾƵ꼤 ŴѧУ԰͵Ůpapa PA wwweee559 ed2k Ⱥ Sex Videos ϼӰ糤 ׽ӰԺ aV 黳ӰԺ貥 С? У԰ɫ ձУٱƵ պƵ ߹ۿ߿ ձƵjllzz պŮ˽ܴ Ѹ Ƶʵ¶԰ СŮ ŮѦ ͵ĸ 5¿첥 ձʮ·Ů AVվè DZ avƬС˵ av eesueeӰԺ www1240 xӰ KPLɫ 2019ݺ Ůͬav߹ۿ ߹ۿ RCT״ս japanese girl voise е gvg118 Ļ ɫɫƵ Ұ ȷӰ 91rone ԻƬ һaƬ ձavʩ ɫ ٸŮ뱻 Դ91 ǿսƵ ձٸXXXƵ yyymp ˿aƬСƵ ԸƵ ԡҵɩɩӰ߸ҿ xiunv225ҹӰԺʦ ׿ ɫ һվ 91aСƵ иƵ ŮɫƵվ 󼦰žžʹٱƵ ɫxxxƵ 춡 Ӱȷ ѪƼϡзŮ goodӰС ӰȷԴ վַ magnet žҹҹո wwwyy6080 t66yʿ Ƶ߲ 1 ձƵy200 84paoֲ 98 ɫɫӰA ϣD ͼƬ aƬ91Ƶ ŷ԰ AV bb ëƬ102ֱ ͼƬС˵ߵӰ ftp 㽶ӰԺ Ӱǿ߲ xxxƵ ѧŮ10p yazhouxingaitoupaizipai δõһα޽ Լ Ӱ ӰƬľϣ ԽƵ ɯ 2017avƵ߹ۿ ҹСӰԺ 159ff magnet Ƶ һʿ԰¼ bƵ Ů avƵ߹ۿ vվ ѹӰƿ÷ Ƭƽ̨ ͵߹ۿ ˮapp 2018õһߵ ľ Դ ڲŴڨŮƵ Ƶ Ұ 15ƵԴٶ Ů иƵXX Ÿ縣 Ƶ һdvd һƬaa AvԱ 0077caoijʲô www AV800 ɫètv ssni168Ļ ˽avebodn qav2345 ӰԺ2017³˿Ƭ ȫƵ Դ 尮߲ ƵŮվ janpenɫϵ ҹӰԺ960 ߹ۿaavv ͼƬ͵ oҲ̤ ҹԼӰԺ ħ4 һ⸣Ƶߵ ŮžžžСƵ ľ嶼Ѹ״ Žֻ ˿߹ۿۺ ͹Ƶƻ ԰鰮 ձŮ˴Ƶ ĻԺ С jufd455 ¶ ¶ӰԺmv dӰԺҹټį ŷr 3DAVthunder ȫAVվ 1034Ƭ ˹Դվ ʪۻƬ ŷպۺ fc2 Сַһ 顡Сgꥹ ݷεվݷȺ IJ ĻӰ ̷ ԰ƵѸ ѧԺŮ̿κ͸ѿֺƨ˺öӰȷ ԸŮ߳Ƶ С̷ӰԺŮ ִٶ Ըи Сͫ СһɫƵ ۻʼӰԺƵ ԽƵй AV߲ porntubֱ СٵĴƵ ԲԲŴ 4438x Ӱ 91ӰԺΣ 2017ƬӰԺ Ӱȷַ ƴƬձvƬ߲ ճ Ƶȫ zӰԺ Ƶ 15PpapapaƵ žžӰԺ 365Ӱ Ƶʦ Ƭ ʵٵƵ߹ۿ ̳ ũAVǹAVӰԺ ˿ ԰¼ ŷئ˿bt ձҳƵ100 ɫۺ ˽ɫ ŻʼҶij magnet Ժʮۺ ˴Ƶվ ۺƵ ͵ οҹɫ СƵ绰ϵ ҰһDVD ͷͷƵ ҵѧСɧ Se678 ɫӰmv ʩ av߹ۿ susu85վijʲô pppd-408 ʵ 3d 㽶 ˽TVӰ www,aƬ, ʹ null SSNI-241 g av Ӱȫ xַ ѸAVԴ ˵Ӱؼ sifangpian WNZS-195 saozixaoshuo Ƶ˸ ٱƸվ susu92 弫ƷŮСɧƵ Ƶre AV߿ ڲŲٱƵʳƷ jjzzzձ԰ɫ ľckۿ ŷavӴ Ů լavӰԺ ˿ܳȹ˿ĦڱС asia_fox 2016ϺģƵ ӰԺŰŰŰ ̳Ƶ ɶ ֻƵ һҳ ٺٺ Ƶ20p ٱxxooƵ Ů a߹ۿ Ƶ xoСƵٶ ĦƵ ҹ707 ÌAƵ4san,com ŸٱƵӰ ʦ˿ջƵ ձeeeex Ծ߽ʦ2015 v2018v80 ò ɫ ɳ ftp СƵ ѳƵ žžžtossgirl ɫɩӰԺ Ů涯̬ͼ ëɫһƬ ¶Ƶ ɫƵ ּ﷬ ҴϷڵƵ 绰 ༦ ڲ yiseziyuanzan Ʒȥվ ĻƵ ˲ٱƵ ipz-576߲ 쿴ҹ ޵һۺƵ Сñվ ¶¶17Ƶ kdh242com free poen ¹-mygirlд ɱȿƵ ˿Ƶ Ļ Ů߹Ƶ ƨ˿ٸС˵ ŷ̬ Ƶ21߹ۿ ˲ ѨץƵ 25se㽶senv аĦʦ߲ һľdvd ձٸëƬ ͵ ѼaƬëƬѹۿ ½Ĵȫ Ƶ߶ С̥ܿ ȭŴȫ ĵ66ҳ Ƭ̬ ͼ ŷ,պ, 127 ùɫɫ 1v1һ㽶 wwwsao69 ˿ŮջƵ ƹ ɫͼƵ sss㽶 2224 Ůר Ƶ߹ۿ õɫƵ ŮҰֱ ҹɬӰԺ ӳǽٶԴ ŮBëƵ ¶ и ŷAVmp4 ftp aƬ ˸ѧ Ӱ GVG-541 thunder Ӱsmd5 ߣŮͼ ٶƵ Ƭ10000Ƶ ի֮ ձŮ˵ˮͼ ŰС˵ ɽ WWW_OMDY8_COM ɫa ձŮѧģ ac8a50ee0002f1b4 Ǵս ŷŮ15pͼ ƨ2 ʦӰӲѯ ޲ٱ WWW_BBS52PK_COM Ů 1ëƬ ɣòٱ ǿŮĹ̹ ŷ԰360 ҳ ɫķ ľС˵ ݺݸɷŮ ߣŮ Ӱȷȫɫ Сۺ ŮʦȫƵ ˼ͲŮƵͼƬ
主播115网盘 大胆日本人体艺术百度 啊用力操好舒服 上原加绘罗番号 欧美艳照门高清 西西人体私穴大胆照 琛¢槼甯傛湁鍠沧甯敺镄勮冻浜ょ殑濂崇殑鍚 网网色大 屄这么松多少人操过你 色五天厕拍 WWW.756NN.COM WWW.LYCYJXX.COM WWW.RQFWJ.COM WWW.BB5278.COM WWW.MYXIGUA.COM WWW.83DDCC.COM WWW.NBSESE1.COM WWW.DAILYNK.COM WWW.470F.COM WWW.COCOD1.COM WWW.DGRTAV.COM WWW.0755MSX.NET WWW.92ITT.COM WWW.AIMSEN.COM WWW.TIENV.COM WWW.DUOXXDUO.COM WWW.JNYSHS.COM WWW.477BO.COM WWW.LIFAN2.COM WWW.TAOPIC.COM WWW.72JEE.COM WWW.CCC566.COM WWW.BBB900.COM WWW.MU444.COM WWW.998QQ.COM WWW.SG50.COM WWW.DY238.COM WWW.TYQZJX.COM WWW.BBB092.COM WWW.HHH421.COM WWW.25JO.COM WWW.CGXIA.COM WWW.423U.COM WWW.CCC973.COM WWW.BBB960.COM WWW.YUFUHS.COM WWW.YQHI.COM WWW.975XX.COM WWW.82293.COM WWW.55TUAN.COM WWW.PPZHIBO.COM WWW.4OYE.COM WWW.452F.COM WWW.13NVNV.COM WWW.44WQ.COM WWW.AV54321.COM WWW.AA191.COM WWW.XYDXTB.COM WWW.SEAVIRI.COM WWW.0915CC.COM WWW.BTLHJ.COM WWW.98FN.COM WWW.65JM.COM WWW.SHBTBY.COM 丁香五月激情gdgd 公公与儿媳妇伦理系列 AAA欧美兽交 亚州成人免费黄色片 www520520eme wwwbbs8haokancn 色姐妹孕妇性爱 社区论坛自拍 制服丝袜变态另类av347yycom av大帝骚色在线视频 最新h网 伦理激视频伦理聚合网址 三级黄播 五月天激情亚洲图片区 gav成人网无播放器免费观看高清 图片区偷拍自动漫 亚洲人成在线 欧美成人群交图片库 wwwbu510com av在线网友自拍 射凉高跟鞋打胶高跟鞋 xb98090 av夜啪啪天啪啪 上了白虎姐姐 www777eycom 手机在线看成人电影av lu福利吧官网 QVOD2017自拍 www611hhhcom 看看夜夜美女 av电影kan212comwwwkan212com 澳门赌场 色狼淫 全本岳母系列肉小说 伦理片福利视频 色妞妞图 搜索myoujizzcominfo 街夜色亚洲视屏 变态另类图片区 大哥撸鲁鲁修 www aaa776 com 超碰免费公开男人在线视频 少妇熟女15 能看的在线av站 狠狠干www92eeeecom 凸凹蝌蚪窝 单位骚熟女图片 色人与兽在线看 美女性交乱轮视频 小色哥色五月 激情都市综合 日韩无码欧洲 好屌妞成人最新 侵犯同学的妈妈彩漫wwwssmm5com 公wwhxhxmagnet www2325con 郑州换妻俱乐部偷拍 kk3343magnet 妹子伦理图片 影音先锋强奸影片 精典国产一级伦理片 85422com 144人体图片 在线电影选项院 超碰黑人成熟视频 色姐姐影院在线 美女生置器图片 www155hucm 恐怖福利影院 操欧美女人逼逼逼 下载什么播放器光看做爱视频 女子自慰在线观看 成人伦理福利合集 淫妈妈网 av乱伦在线观看 亚洲奶水喷射在线视频 李宗盛三级片 最新幼女网址 日本www网站下载 内射良家粉穴先锋 国产自拍小视频晚上碰 7777kjcom开奖直播 av午夜欧美午夜剧场 wwwkkkk25 wwwun7 操妇女50p AV天堂天天色超碰 赵本山的女儿 狠狠撸国语足交 影影音激情 超级avav天堂网 色老婆av wwwwxxx520av 嗯啊不要 五月丁香手机高清无码 另类小说秦大爷 wwwwnnn92com 干逼12p 亚洲性爱欧美色图 色尼姑影音先锋资源 少女日本电影影音先锋 日韩在线ac 俺去也最新人与兽 放荡大奶学妹流了好多水 女主播爱爱在线观看 韩日a片 抱着妹妹看片A片 免费三级金梅瓶 抽插岳母的屄 男人天堂网首页 97成人自慰视频 阿a东方在线 av最大网站在线观看 性爱av色图av 岳母黄色乱伦小说 兽幼小女孩另类 超碰欧美大屁股视频XXX 护士熟母wwwmcc676com 久久草人人艹 萝莉裸下体 66乳交 77v1手机看片 妹妹给我下安眠药全节 伦理人妻magnet 8vaa褋芯屑 泡桐树有毒吗 干湘妹子逼 少妇逼奶子诱惑视频 自拍在线人体 mumu的黄色网站 成人动画网www42nscom 激情综合三级 虐母magnet 色酷色mp4 自偷自拍百度百度 野人性交电影 tsubomi小蕾种子 夏同学网首页在线观看 欧美性爱穴色图 av12直播在线 37pao?co?m 制服丝袜av影音先锋 黑丝美腿三级图片heshizfucom 三级片快播观看mtvqvodcom 一级黄色电影性交片 免费啪啪av va成人影片 色就是色94欧美setu94laxcom 综合征服色的站 童话村黄色电影免费观看 同事夫妇淫乱大浑战小说 偷怕内射 人狗性交的网址 你懂的zoos 野战成人片 sm车神 白虎秀 深爱激情影院 胸贴 碎地在线视频 Www黄 谁有成人免费网站 老婆被轮插的好爽 久久日成人AV 美女老师淫姐 插B十V是啥意思 扩阴器人体 日本高清视频magnet vvvv900 www4k4com 大香蕉免费四号网站 av精∞品视频网址 偷拍自拍走光厕所 dizhi99妹控 黄色淫乱撸片 性爱动漫在线免费 秋霞av免费mqiuxia6com 暗暗撸刀刀 欧美av聚合 在线影院花嫁 大色龟 msusu77com 插插射 黑丝自拍偷拍手机视频 猛操侄女的骚逼 川上网站肛 国产情侣嘿咻 女人能骚到几岁 骚嫂子影院删除 老婆被外国轮流操 幼女幼幼幼交乱伦偷拍 中国三级电影狂 日本大美女抠逼自慰 日本韩国丝袜电影 女人下阴 太一和亚香 私处无遮挡图片 a际成人免费电影 欧美少妇和狗交配图 镞犲咖浜轰綋鑹烘湳 成人免费电影幼交同志 肥穴喷水 强奸校园女老师 影音先锋70岁老太太和孙子做爱 日本激情无码电影网址 那英掰屄 日本熟女av母亲型 WWW_GBGB123_COM 喜欢操老熟女 幼幼片日本 视频 波多野结衣被放芥末 ye321华语影音先锋 红色av社区激情图片 中文字幕成人在线 乱伦少女熟妇 迷奸小妹影音先锋 乱伦文学小姨要我射 操她的骚穴摸她的大奶 电影我爱欲女三邦车视 女性黄图片 小泽玛利亚爱爱谷 小泽利哑裸照 西西人体系艺术极品美鲍人体艺术图片 妻子后妈媳妇日文漫画 妈妈看我肉棒梦精 播播开心激情218成人网 苍井空电影全集1到55 国模汤加丽私拍 我老婆帮我上了她 儿子液侵母亲原照片 吞精 巨乳 660avcm 纲手mm滛乱被轮 山伯淫传之梁母 you鸡zz 成仍激情网 宫本井的黄色 苍井空电影介侣 我要看在线av电影 日本大胆妹妹做爱 骚妹淫 白虎骚妇 快播韩国最新理伦电影 影视演员导演六哥 偷拍男女日屄图片 大奶奶人体 杨颖loudian 裸体做爱动态图 好有肉感好甜美 乱伦家庭故事母子小说 阴茎酷刑的电影 狠狠射自拍偷拍综合区 美女b艺术图 深喉潮吹快播 农夫不准打灰机地址 古籍善本 福州火车票订票电话 华泰证券下载 顾雅莉 计算机培训课程 兰州大闸蟹 konicaminolta 合租情人 十大使徒 骚女h 老太太玩打炮机 顶级电影 初中生和女同学插屁眼图片 美国十啦2014俺去乜最新地址 嫩穴组图 樋口冴子qvod快播 有未处理人体写真 快播伦理偷拍片 春暖花开性另类视频区 男男无忌 祼体louyinbu美女照片 撸一撸色奶奶有妓看 日本一本道人体图片 WWWUUKKMCOM 快播性交姿势 日本护士大胆乳头写真 ef29c71b0000b444 吃逼小说 欧美天堂网手机在线 捷克大奶肥臀熟女卡琳娜贴图 欧洲性感丝袜丰满妓女色女图片 淫三八女儿 成人动漫小次郎视频 神马手机影院电影2017 操你妹妹逼图 淫淫成人片av片 51av分类大陆 东京热本道在线观看 av小池郎 成人小说淫妻换妻图片 第一色成人图片 163com人体艺术 亚洲色色图色色哥 亚洲色图七七影院 成人综合网图 轻易就上愕氖炫从竟獯 亚洲成人第一站 偷看姑姑洗澡五月天自拍 中国美女插大吊图 欧美十次啦导航 qianjgjianluanlunzaixianshipin 人妻乱伦小说春暖花开 香港影院信息 天天色网做爱图片 插插综合图看黄色一级图片 李宗瑞迷奸系列视频全集 在线观看色色影院无需播放器 快播电影怎么传网盘 大屌乱轮小说 刘可颖e2k 干蝴蝶逼 淫色帝国手机版 激情帅哥十八厘米大鸡巴操屁眼 小色比bi 快播电影网活色生香 李宗瑞视频有多少g 色吧淫乱 外国人体艺术有人体艺术 欧美上淫秽图 色久久张柏芝 最大胆美女阴道艺术图片展 WWWSSSCCCLLLCOM 8080av 家庭乱伦操逼网 操了一个模特 wwwqingjunlumagnet 女人被日的图片 www爱色阁qqcom 公司调教嫂嫂小说 女人露全乳图片 户外极品美女情欲 淫香淫色最新网站 妓女青色网 www96iseinf 仓多真央中文字幕 色狗快播成人网址 wwwzzzbbbbcom 张芘张筷雨美丽一生 m1905手机版电影网 www久久操中文字幕 免费观看一级日本毛片 石黑京香在线无插件jpxieavcom 亚洲色图美腿丝袜松果儿 怡春院弟一色院 の淫らな教师ハード黑コア 4p换妻露脸 wwwyda3info 美女视频免费播放啪啪百度百度 被全班轮奸的女生琪琪 老色哥奇米影视26uuu 9czxkan 反恐精英伊莎邪恶图片 以色列XXX百度 花花公子人休艺术成人导航网 juse五月 熟女性爱系列 噜噜噜AV在线小姨子观看 楼道口强暴少女影院 乱伦小说欧美图片另类图片 母子乱伦性交在线视频wap17nnnncom 123操逼百度 wwwav小日本网站 丝袜制服绿 全裸美女狠 强x幼幼小萝莉 手机久久看伦理电影免费 黄色片毛片三级片首页 日本少女xxx超碰 777sejingwang 日刘亦菲 欧州最大成人踪合 www路mumu98路commp4 性吧网址导航 16处女JIZZ 欧美胖妞性爱电影 欧美大胆嫩肉穴爽大片 av网插女 极品抽插 狠干刘亦菲大屁股 wwwdiyesao 韩国妇女吃精 空中女乘务员性福小说 性故事国中妈妈 偷拍裸借图片大全 啪啪图激烈的勉费视频 羽毛搔菊花 五月桃唇magnet 偷窥自拍达盖尔 淫欲军团 81xacom韩国料理 美臀美腿小阿姨 亚洲成人快播电影网www080xxcom 有声小说狼牙 寻春色12街 樱井莉亚电影 谁有手机黄网啊 www.vip.shop www小沈阳cn 开心五月五月天 东京热n187 东京热新女 为什么酒色网 快播看黄片 女儿看黄片 能看黄色小说的网站 www黄色小说 真夏的花园 女人丰乳 在线影院 99色电影 大色哥影院 夫妻娱乐网 后庭花AV 就色色成人 师傅搞电影 新亲密爱人 八个色A片网 好色妹妹激情 秘密花园论坛 淫荡性爱大片 009hh综合 色姐姐高清影院 淫淫乐综合娱乐 百撸 他也撸 撸一哈 大色哥导航 色蝴蝶网 大学生黄婷婷h版阅读 电影H站 亚洲×Ⅹx 橘梨纱456 胜间靖子 东京热在线播放第一季 苍老师a片 深爱五月综合缴情综合 综合图片亚洲色偷自拍 皇家Lu23 福利奶水自拍视频 jlzzjlzz现在播放 相泽唯衣 番号 全球最大4438x 全裸美女照正面视频发 性感女秘书肉丝超短裙加班时被经理扑倒操爽后说 我等下要喷潮了 好痒啊 你快点 办 人妻国产在线 小学女生三级湿影院 邪恶e漫画口供无遮挡了3d 越南美女磁力下载 在线国产视频精品视频 日本视频一区在线播放 樱空桃资源在线观看 日本一本道电影eeuss 日本女人色透视频 影音先锋日本乱伦影片 影音先锋资源站男人网 有色hd高清国产视频 日木伦理电影影片中文版 韩国vip 看操逼大片 奇乐影院理论片 国产朋友老婆对白 古墓丽影香奈尔h片在线看 上海会所高颜值双飞 国产手机自拍福利视频 我爱干比b在线观看 美女无码自慰 唐琪儿福利视频视频 jizzzzz meyd165协和影视 五月婷婷心爱 日本乱片最新 俺去也Av 亚洲AV搬运工 手机变态另类AV在线 japanese girl voise 香蕉资源 久草福利自拍 米卡本子 番号作品介绍片段 影音先锋AV映画官网防屏蔽 btshare 交易所 乡下小学女生的性生活视频 国产强奸自拍视频 pppd-711迅雷 秋霞成人剧场一本道dvd 日本一道本东京热视频 色女色女影院 内射大学女生视频 电影 桃奶木 一级剧情午夜片 超碰福利伦理 妹妹干美国网站 你懂的网站在线观看AV 亚洲自拍性爱多P 阿 v 天堂 潘春春夜火完整版迅雷下载 乌克兰aⅴ毛片~ 热产热国产自拍 92看看1000集在线播放 超粉嫩10岁妹子嫩肉嫩穴 大香蕉av猫喵在线 红楼78电影网 播五月婷婷缴清综合站 欧美性xo 国内自拍宾馆6p真人视频 僵尸艳谭2手机在线 守望先锋AV网站 家族轮奸 ed2k 四虎防屏蔽 wwwffff888con 羽田真理无码AV片 ed2k 可爱大人里番在线观看 国产剧情网红在线播放 ww8o6o伦理片 欧美Av3d动漫的网站 楼道校花mp4 一边看书一边自慰番号 黄色网站88888888 woailan 线上学生a片 李小璐21秒S啪 人间观察av 天天影视av 明日花绮罗xfplay pu370网址 欧美动漫AV卡通 搜查官网站 Av视频兔 激情亚洲手机版 苍井空 26uuu天海翼 柚木 大桥未久色色 京香julia 西瓜影音 mini按摩黄色一级片 亚洲成av人片在线观看大尺度 关于色狐狸的网站 大香蕉新人人现 磁力链 下载上原凯洛 触手H动漫在线看 处女轮奸视频 yy4480日本污片视频 动漫美女被肉棒虐的视频 岛国男女叉视频 xxoo 韩国无码 动漫伦理 璃莎 xx4s4scc 97zy资源站成年人在线看 saobulu 在线免费视频你懂得 主播西西合集 磁力下载 色浮网大香蕉 香港三级福利 欧美成人无码在线视频 p手机在线视频 皮裤做爱 草民影院4k x–art短发迅雷 武藤兰系列丝袜 www4455dpcom 青青草原剧场 三级片播放平台 亚洲潮喷国产在线视频 1024美女跳蛋自慰福利 小清新影院1240福利视频 夜夜操视频免费看 日韩电影高清欧美有码 538在线精品免费搬运工 91视频福利靠逼 成人电影偷拍自拍照 深喉 口爆视频69 字幕 日韩 九哥 北京 不卡无码免费伦理片 生岛凉 迅雷下载 国产主播av观看网站 色色资源站 ftp 操任你操 538在成人免费视频在线观看 aⅴ淘宝在线视频观看 韩妞在酒吧被黑鬼下药 优衣库在线视频影院 谭晓彤 福利 视频 在线 明星资源视频 圣爱天堂男人视频 4123 2018亚洲 动漫在线av b雪福利导航 欧美日b激情视频 大香蕉视频在线频影院 黑吊扩阴视频 火影同人肉片视频源 j8aa52 水菜丽颜射房间 黄色视频小说网站 摸鸟门迅雷磁力 影音先锋阿姨不约 怡红院av视频免费 色拍拍久久播在线观看 xfplay天海翼 协和 西西怡红 微拍视频小马电影 av色天堂。五月 wwwsexiu94 草草人人人 色色色男人天堂 U07,禁言福利群 扶她部 rct–493 欧美套图 肌肉男被摸肌肉视频 久久热人妻免费视频 正在播放口爆吞精的美女 艾薇资源共享吧 晓骚咪 小少妇偷拍自拍视频 雅丽沙视频全集 小小野麻里亚在线Av 学生妹诱惑福利合集 magnet 先锋色色成人电影 丝袜色色小说 淫淫色色成人视频 先锋影音浅井舞香 邪恶 道acg漫画里番全彩3d 日本中学生体内射精 4438全亚洲最大成人视频 伦理自拍福利小视频 japanese人妻中文字幕 91在线开车 在线强奸电影 wwwd111m黄色姐姐 人人操不卡 蓝路导航 松本麻里奈免费公开视频 校园春色欧美视频 穴湿了 日本成人做爱老湿影院 丝袜台湾apk 二级黄片在线播放 校园厕所偷拍小女视频高清 淫欲吧视频在线观看 中国人性爱视频免费观看 吃下面的视频 mp4 日本图书馆暴力强奸在线免费 搜狗色五月开心在线视频 kanav在线观看 52s社区 魅男天天海龙 番性奴 欧美黄A片天天影院 人妻少妇偷拍视频图片 乡村电影网站宅宅最好看的 在线 AV 年影 舒淇年轻电彰 国产情侣偷拍下一站 青青青成人免赞自拍 杨幂1分11秒西瓜在线 小红帽AV免费在线观看 xooⅹ430 彼得老哥色 东方aⅴ在线观永久 国产av自拍手机版 成年丁香 国产自拍ac 波多野吉衣2018在线理论 厕所偷拍直播 波波视频东京热 草榴影院中的黄色视频 国产午夜骑兵 操鸡巴免费版 米奇影视盒狠狠 婷婷五月丁香基地 野结衣 ftp 巨乳床上大尺度视频 秋霞eee 亚洲图片紧急更换域名 厕所偷拍a中国无码视频 不要充值就可以看AV的软件下载 vv影厍 波多野结衣轮奸在线播放 TGGP78在线观看 北川美绪伦理在线 成人快摇电影网免费视频 国产内射射精 美女自卫在线视频手机视频 国产网红主播福利视频亚洲色图 美女扣b直播平台 裸体视频 下载 上门口交 冰与火h版 色婷婷开心五月色综合 湿舔视频 128 福利片 香蕉 啪啪在线自拍视频 草莓100社区视频 福利视频 剧情演绎 梦乃爱华影音在线播放 欲情影音先锋 花椒相机福利美女视频 小黄瓜伦理 男女啪啪1000粒视频 久久人av 黑丝白肉我珍藏的av女优 高清无码喷水迅雷 ed2k 男人叼嘿女人真人视频 操逼尿视频 操美女25p 国产自拍美腿 波士哥作品 特别企划真实巨乳空姐黑丝制服 裸体搞p视频 日本轻熟女优优 magnet 人数最多女同番号 午夜快成播 天堂电影日韩性交视频 爱丽莎lisaLU福利 日本人兽 下载 年轻的空姐伦理片迅雷下载 福利社午夜直播频道 黄色影院乱伦图片成人影院 超比啪啪在线播放 色欲在线福利 夜色黄色影院↗ 自抠穴视频 人体艺t木摄影 国产偷拍_第3页_av天天有 787影院午夜福利 足控百度云 camporn国产自拍 做爱视屏现场版 日本巨乳成人 自拍操喷水逼视频 色和尚 露奶啪啪美女视频福利2网站 猫咪av大香蕉有线视频 色表妹色 六月丁香深爱五月婷婷 裸体高潮成人影院app 噜噜噜操逼视频 裸体艺术做爱视频网 萝莉户外直播自慰福利 家庭性交搞基视频 轻舔花 火影忍者邪恶agc漫画纲手邪恶道 鸡巴屄 强奸福利小视频免费在线观看 同性做啪啪啪过程视频 4438xx5 西瓜影音 日韩性爱快播 花嫁高柳家在线 av香蕉影院 www,caoborn,com 外企老总爆干天朝区代理 炮广西妹子Tawtaw这妹子有点像那 托里布莱克磁力mag AMSR欢欢百度云视频 西瓜影院福利导航 白石未央百度云 处女体内射精视频直播 柚木rio 在线影院 hlwnds88 夜用影院 巨乳女教师在线视频观看 蓝色导航最新发布地址 男女鲁鲁动态视频 丝瓜影视 黄片立花?莉 黑丝美女自慰 黄色视频美女直播自慰 狼人无码 magnet k8fldh 大香蕉狼狼日伊人 爆乳黄色小视频 神屌伏娇百度云 在线福利短片视频网站 亚洲图片 自拍 制服 桥本凉a片 亚洲国产三级在线 成人免费141tube 老师邪恶影院a 日韩快播怡红院 456电影网葵司在线观看作品 AV影画 zipaisipai 欧美enen 欧美丝美女 magnet 真人超大但在线视频 动漫美女贝艹 美国老太a∨视频免费 最新亚洲福利视频 裸体视频 mp4 色棍影院 好大不要嗯啊抽插高潮 国产在线 少妇主播 学生 男女互插视频2018 男人叉美女dd 内蒙包头小骚女办公室小露脸自拍第三弹 超级艳舞 免费在线福利主播 色戒在线线播放视频 国产偷拍自拍在线视频网站 1冲田杏梨黄片视频 黄蓉和狗 magnet yunfile影片 东北口音黄片 丰乳肥臀啪啪啪啪全集 激情视频激情小说伦理电影 八哥电影手机版最快宅宅网 AV同性真人 与僧侣相交色欲番号 教师无修改动漫av 日屄屄视屏 福利免费电影第一导航所 葡萄视频主题酒店 韩国自拍福利合集 sanji免费视频直播 丁香区大香蕉视频 人妖视频收索3681 家庭幻想乱伦小说 表妹打奶炮 熟女星艳图 明日花性交删除 椅以谙? 影音先锋老男人av网 搜视频图片人体艺术 男人叉女人的动漫视频 人体艺术插妹妹 影音先锋异种奸学园~魔兽的巨大阴茎被侵犯 她也色淫荡视频 女人做爱多了下面会是什么样子 a片在线看 俄罗斯大胆人体写真 91pom视频网站 网友自拍插逼视频 母子游戏时不小心插入妈妈体内 电驴怎么搜黄 中欧人体美鲍艺术 泰国少女性爱图片 人体艺术摄影poco 亚洲狂插 我的动物情人狗与马 极品白富美爆操15p 汤芳最暴露人体艺术图 颜仟汶写真 avsedy百度影音 幼女女优写真 插日本mm 毒岛冴子福利图 西西国模超大胆露雹写真 欧美虐阴电影网址 藤冲有关的电视剧 99女人网人体艺术 真人裸体艺术视频 人体写生女性生殖器写真 汤加丽裸体露阴毛 偷拍自拍人妻交换删除 偸拍骚妇 裸体性感欧洲帅哥 日韩拳头塞逼快播 黄梦露吃翔 em6666com 欧美成人爱爱 经典三级狠狠鲁 情人的骚b图 欧美口交操逼 日本人体艺术图pian WWW_05SUSU_COM setu38p 磁力链接麻美 老人屄 国内某公司领导把自己90后秘书弄到宾馆给干了 李嘉欣骚逼 操逼小哥哥 密穴乱伦小说 人体高清套图 青山菜菜 白妇教师和黑人学生 啄木鸟另类小说欧美 人体艺术小明看看 色网 把美女的美腿吊起来的强奸小说 情人的鸡巴比动物的还大 人妻路拍自拍 亚州无码区春暖花开性吧有你 性爱视频青青草 色小说乱伦故事 撸中撸孕妇系列 10岁女孩的屄是什么样子 李宗瑞 2973 欧美兽片bt 亚洲奇米影视 日本人体性生活视频 mm成人贴图 快播刺激网址 变性后人体图片欣赏 少妇大奶30p 日本本国艺术写真 在线视频偷拍女人性交视频 苍井空bt种子搜索 神勇大汉操逼图 丁香成人综合社区 熟女和小伙做爱 男同性性交片 嫩模jiaojiao 大胆妹妹窝 骚货刘亦菲 w我要草比网 流璃岛人体艺术照 444色网 美女淫荡性交图片 WWW_88BBU_COM 教师性爱图片 紧的屄 肏逼最新图片 女人裸体漏逼图片 儿媳的靓屄 266uuu26uuu 姐夫半夜开了我的苞 淫贱婊子网 真人女性的两片嫩肉 哑巴生煎 井江野山茶油怎么样 hd598 情欲满载全集播放 812 名人劈腿扒逼图 我和妈妈性爱并生孩子 骚妇少妇妹妹小色哥农夫婷婷大胆图片 偷窥厕所五月露脸 69色色图 把淫荡的姐姐妹妹搞得直求饶 哥哥就要操 日本人体艺术白虎阴户 电脑哪里可以看禁片成人电影 最新夫妻交换 五月天裸体照 一本道拍摄的电影 色妹妹人妖 绫波优南岛sex 阿娇吃鸡巴图 欧美屄图快播伦理电影片 百度美女被强奸视频 ouzhoujiqing3 成人涩塞 欧美淫荡人体套图 全裸小穴美女图片 日本性感大鸡巴 超碰抠逼逼 交外人体艺术照片 霪霪网在线视频免费 大屁股大奶子的av 大路惠美 插18有人体摄影网 少妇嫩穴15 四房色播网页图片 黄色操逼片写zhen 色哥色网 深夜操逼图片激情图片网 日屄很爽 美国女人和狗性交 快播亚洲激情欧美另类人妖 淫荡综合色网 色妹妹我要啊v yazhousetu26p 偷玩中年妇女真实故事 百度人体写真 合成论坛 王麟多少钱一晚上 偷拍熟女露鲍 乱论大鸡巴 撸啊咂色视频 农村乱情 WWWXFYSLUBCOM 游戏王明日香 西方乱妇19p图片 偷拍自拍摸b摸 淫乱足交 私人影院能看什么电影 亚州色图就射 正在播放胖奶奶 成人幼幼免费伦理片 欧美18p性爱视频 我在办公室插妈妈骚逼 苍井空大胆写真图片 丝袜逼骚 姐姐和弟弟操逼 淫妻小洁 亚洲色图~色色男 人体庄媛 日韩多p人体 初中女生屄部的相片 最新美女写真影院 快播户外乱伦电影 哥哥日日妹妹 弟弟插妹妹的故事 操女秘书小穴 七十路老熟女 爆菊花电影wap78nucom 男的和女的操逼视频 操着的骚逼逼 cytherea作品 拉丁美淫淫 白女16p 人体艺术图片西西全裸照片露阴部 久久日干学生妹视频 小姨子陈琳逼 黑鸡吧恶 亚洲色图cosplay 人体的屄 ai人体艺术图片 苍井空高清无码照片 铃木av www8se9se 成人处女被操视频 WWWNV888COM 色歪歪网站 十五岁女孩嫩穴 人妻凌辱图 湿润肥穴好粗 478ddse 阴户视频xxx 少妇找大吊日 周涛五月天 色老肥妈 免费成人在线视频网址 最简单科学孝明大全 美女明星高清激情大胆色图 韩国色qingdian影 处女素人娘 欧美性爱图第一页 风骚女会计 怡红院高清在线 亚洲辣图天天综合 赤条少妇大图片 美女丝足美穴 青青草免费在线xxuu33com 亚洲深爱婷婷五月丁香 黄色激情小说好色小姨 人体艺术美女浪逼图片 偷拍自拍xxx日本特级片xxxx日本最新 zhangmuniangshipin SSV资源 极品人妻援交系列套图 AV换妻电影 强脱衣服小说 wwwyoujiuzzcom 亚洲明星黄 32saocom青娱乐 百度多酷游戏中心 国产情侣AV偷拍视频mbaiducom 小伊伊mp4 灌肠肛交另类电影 乳房流奶水图pain 亚洲武侠小说 激情小农妇 爽磁力 女色狼社区 黄色艳情影片肛交 校园春色古典武侠嫩穴 专业做爱 亚洲美女太色了 亚洲色图偷拍hd 旗袍黄色电影 千王1991magnet 十大中字无码动漫名字 同学的妈妈色电影 日本奸淫下体电影 7788mp3有声读物 插处女的时候什么感觉 啦啦队宝贝av资源 av亚洲天堂妹妹wwwc5508com www表子com 色欲图书馆 偷拍自拍插妹妹小穴 日本a片强奸乱伦母亲 巨乳诱惑福利在线播放 搜索超碰黄色片三级片 琪琪se原网址 妹妹爱意淫 中国骚逼被操 喜欢本站的朋友请将swwwgg514com lol娑娜 狠狠曰狠狠干wwwssav88com 女友分类的网站 旅馆叫床视频m56comvqqcommvqqcom 美剧天堂西瓜影音百度黄色大电影 亚洲色淫图百度 情人节超清偷拍与美少妇激情在线观看 中亚magnet tokyohot亚洲激情 911色色色影音 5xww1com5xww1com 色尼姑Av五月天 波多野结衣ng完整视频mdyguocom 色狼短片videopaebaiducom youjizz有机zz 美国网站泳装软件 南国成人网 大陆免费毛片对白 爱色wap54ixcom 撸男人成人 wwwxbfe 日韩中学生做爱视频迅雷下载 亚洲最大的色青青草wwwqqsp1com 无码中文字幕塞外青楼这是一个 biantailinglei 北京furenda教育发展 3d里番哪里可以在线看 影音先锋色表妹诱惑 欢乐吧怎么看黄 红杏综合 wwwaznidmolgmcn 类似四房色播 菅野亚梨沙76部 跟黑人老婆的下场人体艺术 丝袜让人体艺术 ed2k深田恭子 taiwan3jipian 性爱故事武侠热情都市言情亚洲色图 阿拉伯伟哥 美腿丝袜操逼 欧美顶级人体艺妓 色人阁黄色小说2 快播强奸乱伦qvwod qingse97 高青自怕夫妻操逼 韩国电影偷拍自拍 孙允珠porn 如何用丝袜 AV小日本 星河大帝同人小说 家庭乱伦成人影音先锋 www77kksscom 人妖动漫学生妹 色CC伦理影院手机版 欧美自拍都市激情 wwwmeinvmei222 成人院下载 男女性l交小说 av在线网友自拍 蝌蚪窝在线成人动漫 全色资源在线视频 久草中文幕 成人黄色小说网乱伦小说网站 手机在线免费观看情涩视频快播 wwwwcon520XXid 卡通动漫第一页综合 富家女堕落为性奴 男亲女私处图片 妹撩哥网站 色图12P 18av青青草在线视频 丨蝴蝶谷成人AV 伊人成视频范冰冰 世界第一av资源 日本母子强奸乱伦 meiguose 鸥美色图库 小色哥色五月 美女自摸内裤自慰视频 日本萝莉av小视频在线 重口味变态另类第1页 碰碰拳交视频 女儿湿滑稚嫩的肉洞 国语对白国产自拍久久 日本啪啪小电影在线 色尼姑五月婷婷 宾馆自拍偷拍视频 妹子伦理图片 我被性感阿姨ooxx了 成人黄色色图电影 四月天五月成人小说 在线观看欧美家庭淫乱 夫妻自拍撸 乱囵xiaoshuo 33mnbcomi 91国内手机视频在线 亚洲高清毛片 啊扣你的小穴 成人电影_偷拍自拍_亚洲图片_欧美图片_成人在线电影WWWAVAV91 大学生爆菊在线视频 我不卡影院magnet JAVHDftp dvd色亚州av 黄片日本magnet 另类合集小说在线阅读 嘿嘿路 免费观看同性恋学生妹三级视频 日本姓交大视频在线 四虎视频在线 四虎免费黄色网站 www、gaoav 快播AV在线观看视频 樱井步在线视频观看 京香肛交 中文字幕在线视频avwww2pidcom aiseiwang 偷偷的插入了 蝌蚪窝日日操曰曰撸 舔了你的逼啊啊 超碰在前视频 美女做爱Av毛片 嫩汁50p 亚洲·性视频 www玩捧Tv 雅蠛蝶影视网观看 亚洲图片亚洲欧美偷拍另类图片 seri123一样的网站 WWW033secon 色老头全集 黄色少女 撸一撸欧洲色图操逼 图片区视频区偷拍自拍欧美图片 960AAA 一本道美乳AV 亚洲啊T天堂 裸模 美脚妻の交尾影音先锋 小芹偷拍自拍视频 www54qqqcom 1138x成人wang 美国AV黄网 av网无毒 WWW288hhcn 天天啪啪 爱爱王国 人妻按摩乱伦 性爱电影毛片 www789黄色播放器 性涩影音app 撸二哥男人在线迅雷看看 伦乱片236 韩国mm影音 六月天偷拍撸啊撸 小泽玛利亚女上男下 人奶少妇人体 以女性为主色小说 236zzcon 在线视频免费观看拍拍 请色 5b5b88com亚洲 www76升级页 www5799com 不要钱播放器看AV 色呢姑色呢姑l 自拍偷拍制服丝袜校园春色 wwwff635con下载 苍井空电影全部名字 李xx强奸幼幼内射篇 www590uucom 超碰幼女做爱 黄色网站用影音先峰 唯美欧美内射magnet WwWr4747com seselululu 绳捆女人一级片 淫乱日本动漫 公车强奸母女 娇妻的忏悔张业哪能看 橹鸡巴 范冰冰性交视频下载 亚洲免费熟女做爱 搜索81xacom 欧美性奴av 女性播放器大片女人 公然妄想露出在线 zoosexviedeo 写真mp4巨乳 我与美女楔做爱的故事 韩国女主播黑丝叉叉 小姨子骚货 中文字幕视频在线观看的伦理电影网 redtuberedtubecomwwwredtubepl 骚逼女人自慰图 dizhi99日本老熟妇 草裙性生活视频 舔妻子的白嫩美脚 92359日韩色熟女酒井电影 蕾在线 wwwhh99mocom 谁有成人免费网站 phoenixmarie小男人 无毛教师潮喷三尺36D大奶网 性爱色狼 秋霞伦理片av 影音先锋急先锋 色妈乱伦在线视频 欧美性交成人网站 亚洲欧美色片在线播放 5x社区视频免费观看 228df看不了 给我一个a片网站下载 B撸 色色爰 6699mp4 丝袜美腿亚洲色图先锋 制服丝袜小说手机在线 免费av96 AV色逼 女性无码迅雷 淫妻交换美丽女邻居 男根的诱惑系列 操空姐亚洲色图 女同按摩系列小说 石门情报站全本txt 骑士酒色1234 白虎小穴被早 欧美极品嫩穴 我最喜欢的熟女15p 美女美穴人体graphis 色亚洲吉吉 高清人体电影 美妞黑木耳尿尿 苍井空露阴道阴毛图片 淫荡少女与种猪交配 插死她电影网快播 肏笓片 欧美美女床戏 下载黄色片播放器 和老太太上床 曰本美女狠插 少妇巨乳诱惑影音先锋 男女大胆性交图 粗黑鸡巴操骚逼图 漂亮性感凶虎 自拍偷拍近亲乱伦 ed2k 欧美幼女 夫妻3人p视频 老农和几个大学色女生的淫荡生活 骚穴辣图 黄色网站来一个视频 美女颜射左爱肛交p 大黑逼自拍偷拍 人老逼不老16p 少妇人体艺术成人导航 快播春护士 被侵犯的美女教师天海翼rmvb 挺入妹妹小 偷拍自怕美女色图 张柏芝艳照片全集下载huawei 美女uu电影 WWW_168200_COM 波多野结衣美女丝袜bt电影下载 夫妻宾馆操逼大胆自拍 问叶2骚屄 肏屄有多爽 鏈€嚭鍚嶇殑鎬х埍缃戠珯 肏逼美奴 黄色日批照动态 vvvv888com 大鸡巴的一篇 欧美萝莉少女口交 狗于女人做爱的故事 夫妻zi拍在线看 旭魔3成人黄色网站 苍井空的电影名字 妹妹汁液 色妹妹成人动漫 欧美女人口交 五月成人夕激情网 波野结衣av快播 女兵肛交 2kkvv 人体艺术瓣yin 极度乱伦图片 大陆 淫乱多人大换妻 迅雷模特写真 黄色片17一18男女做爱 妹妹乱伦快播 偷拍自拍网私密情趣 香洪武侠电影 色吧影院幼女性交 txt全集电子书 伯乐与千里马 资生堂防晒霜 芮成刚 女性杂志 黄粲扒皮 理疗有副作用吗 骚女h 先锋影音闫凤娇 偷拍性美女 WWWSAO65COM 羽月舷成性吧 伟大的妈妈小说黄色 友达の母亲系列 艳臀淫母 怡红院怡春院大香蕉 岛国自拍网站 美女淫穴插入 www111女生殖器 小西的熟妇盛宴txt删除 手机泡泡影院手机高清 色妹妹爽死了~图片 不用播放器的av 我和表姐偷情 偷拍熟女自慰视频 360jjj 色播视频免费的 快播ay 欧美av性感写真 兰桂坊亚洲成人图 教师操屄 黄色片人与兽性交 姐夫和小姨子淫爱 性感丝袜美女图库欧美色图欧美色图 ppp36图片 牛牛碰在线视频 免播下载性爱电影 轮伦美女 做爱插逼逼图片 cup黄网 WWW23E3COM 好看的黄小说 沙发上骑姐姐 影音先锋在线观看成人电影 性生活duppid1duppid1 林雨欣小雄性事全集mp3 屄屄图图 欧美激清阴道 苍井空爆操女人前后 欧美三级电影 趣向人体丝袜图片 圣后骚货 让干电影 乱伦小说综合资源网 狂操骚妹小穴 美女老婆被轮奸小说网 张雨筱裸照照 抱着老婆的大屁股爱爱 湿嫩粉逼 美女裸体小鸡鸡图片 处女色穴 浙江母子真实乱伦 欧美少妇骚货做爱性高潮 哪里有欧美高清性感图啊 优妹影院 胖女人的爽爽 免费a片无播放器 我爱考逼21 竹内玛利亚车站改编 国产av三级色色网 人休芝术摄影 有大鸡鸡的女孩子先锋 亚洲图片欧洲美图日本Av成人伦理成人有声小说 小熙调教视频在线观看www51gannet 不知火舞hentalvideo WWWQQMATOUCOM 色女孩qq号免费 娇妻被淫记朱茵 自拍熟女吉吉影音 bta18con 黄电影电视小说乱论免费看 spanking秒拍 强奸电影名字 成人操成人叫成人干 81h6699us 西安洗浴双飞三通全套 linda巨乳人妻系列 空间更新av 明星合成伦乱图区 日本不雅网站 fulilt水仙 成人三级片黄片毛片 火影忍者AVmagnet 欧美色吧美女艺术照 丝袜小学生网址 偷拍自拍老色女 漫画少女粉鲍 我爱原味免费视频 海外华人av网 欧美淫色奇米影视 肏逼微博 苍井空点影 操妈妈的大黑逼 yy6080网站图片 15p嫩妹妺 黑寡妇色小说 乱伦在线免播放器 日本少归内衣 多毛妻子 一本道qvod全球 趁夜色轮奸少妇 神马影院斗鱼 黄片谁拍恋足 777sejingwang 兰桂坊成社人区小说www68kqcom 亚洲图片欧美图片日韩伦理 豪色con 干岳母老女人 swww104sihucom最新 偷拍商钞爱视频直播 日本护士自慰快播 xxxxx操逼 www123bbbb色欲影视 东京热四p大乱斗 5252avavavhaos01 驱蚊草对人有害吗 叶玉卿情不自禁qvod 类似q2002的网址 女性videopaebaiducom 不想停sex母香港三级片 反夜了 亚洲欧美制服人妻师生 欧美裸体Av图片 不卡的av在线黄色网站 动漫性感美女被吸奶 笨gir 色色网五月花色色网 av大帝电台 亚洲小说图片偷拍电影下载区 AV里老少 李老师操了我 草馏口交 欧肏屄视频 顶级人体艺术色色图 爱春色 下到樱井莉亚片子 小泽玛利亚3人 小泽玛利亚现今 小泽玛利亚后门 求火影h网 谁有最新的手机黄网 www.唯品网 优质东京热 酒色网 快播 qq空间看黄片 5252黄色小说 就去色色 欲望之都 百度骚导航 苍井空与狗 菊花色综合 六月天美眉 要你射电影 三洞齐插电影 我爱幼幼论坛 007成人电影 淫骚成人爽电影 琪琪se 撸一哈 射射 mum—002在线播放 爽爽影院怎么破解 爱的色放西瓜 淫的的方式程在线观看 五月丁香六月综合缴情视频 caoporn网页 大尺度床视直播软件 免费40分钟毛片看 日韩高清无码午夜 magnet 在线wwwffff15con av帮售 gav成人免安装播放 任你操在线视频我们只是视频的搬运工 一号影院 mp4 www,Fac158 av不卡无码高清视频 超碰国产自拍无码 人群穿戴自慰器 magnet 国产在线av 神马电影网亚洲无码 色色ev sw-167 某航空公司空姐与男友酒店激情 嗯大学校园偷拍男女papa PA视 wwweee559 ed2k 群交 Sex Videos 高清 秋霞电影社长夫人 亲姐弟性伦影院 亚洲aV 情怀影院无需播放器 小宫由梨? 校园春色五月天 日本校花操逼视频 日韩视频在线 在线观看成人线看 日本人六九视频jllzz 日韩美女私密处 免费福利网 酒店真实高清露脸对白 小女友 美女薛婧裸体外阴艺术 自偷自拍福利在线 5月快播 日本四十路熟女 在线 AV网站猫咪官网 韩国明星悲惨世界李宗瑞 av动画肉片小说 av兔子 在线骑兵步兵eesuee影院 www1240 x老子影视 KPL色佬 2019狠狠射 女同性av在线观看 恋爱秀秀在线观看 RCT近亲大作战在线 japanese girl voise 爆乳家政妇 肉感的 gvg118 四虎 高清无码 自拍 澳门来色色视频 久野 先锋影音 91rone国产 免费曰本高清三级片 韩日一级a片 日本av豆腐西施种子 网色亚洲在线 少妇女高中生想被插 网上资源91 强暴空姐视频 日本少妇XXX视频 yyymp 成人看a片小视频 超级性感视频番号 浴室的嫂嫂韩国电影在线敢看 xiunv225恋夜影院教师 国产打底裤 自拍 随风阁黄色 第一会所导航福利网站 91aⅤ小视频 孕妇做暧昧视频 窝窝美女色视频网站 大鸡巴啪啪使劲操逼视频在线 色狼xxx视频 五月天丁花香缴情网 影音先锋 欲求不满 喷血推荐稀有房女神级 good电影神马小丢 影音先锋黄油资源 激情网站地址 广西主播西西 magnet 天天啪夜夜日日日干 wwwyy6080 t66y上榴人士 潮吹视频在线播放 第1集 日本视频y200 84pao独乐乐不如众乐乐 98国产自拍 拉风色中色影视AⅤ 希咲彩 图片 a片91视频 欧美性爱网进口 爆乳天堂AV bb 毛片基地102在线直播 另类亚洲图片小说在线电影 惊天铁案 ftp 大香蕉影院 电影强奸在线播放 xxx在线视频 大学女友10p yazhouxingaitoupaizipai 初音大桥未久第一次饼亚洲结束 饭冈加奈子 丁丁影视 哚哚影视理论片佐佐木明希 岛国人与兽性交视频 动漫伦理 璃莎 2017av视频免费在线观看 中夜小影院 159ff magnet 巨乳王瑞儿在线视频 一个护士的性爱录音 草b在线免费视频 美女 黄av免费视频在线观看 东方阿v在线网站 搜狗电影金瓶梅 三级片播放平台 偸拍自偷在线观看 水果湾app 2018幺妹第一福利在线导航 荒井萌三级 资源草 正在播放搭讪熟女视频 最污柔术见鲍鱼线视频 星野朱莉种子 莉哥15分钟视频资源百度云 国产女主播 下载 孕妇视频XXⅩ 九哥福利网导航 无码视频性 一本道久清在线dvd 美国一级黄片aa 黑人Av淘宝 0077cao改成什么了 www AV800 色猫tv ssni168中文字幕 人交兽avebodn qav2345 神马影院2017鲁丝片 不正规的全身推油视频 福利哥免费资源 玲村爱里在线播放 左左视频美女最新网站 janpen色系 午夜影院960 免费在线观看aavv 图片区亚洲另类偷拍 美脚社区o金币踩踏 午夜约吧影院 淫魔病棟4 一库福利视频在线导航 男女啪啪啪小视频 木村都那迅雷磁力链接 国产脚交手机在线 丝袜在线观看综合 凹凸夫妻视频青苹 性爱情爱爱爱 日本女人吹潮视频 快插伦理 四虎院城 小鸡巴在线 jufd455 相对宇宙 露点 谷露影院mv 三d影院深夜不再寂寞 欧洲r 级 3DAVthunder 全部AV在线网站 1034看片 俄罗斯在线资源站 湿污黄片 欧美亚洲日韩在线综合网在线 fc2 小明发看看加密网址一 爆乳 小沢アリス 青青草防屏蔽导航网站青青草夫妻秀群 宾馆里操情人身材不错 四虎影 咸番 下载 性爱短视频迅雷链接 学院派女神翘课和富二代男友开房真会玩舔脚趾屁眼射了好多影音先锋 性感美女被插高潮福利视频 小姨夫影院幼女 现代三级百度云 性感福利视屏 小林瞳磁力 小人橹一橹色在线视频 香港皇家影院视频 性交视频中国 筱田优AV在线播放 porntub成人直播 把小姐操的大叫视频 李圆圆古代三级 黄4438x 西瓜影音 91影院危险吗 2017理论片右手影院 东方影库正确地址域名 黄大片日本阿v片在线播放免费 菊池蓝完整版 晚上碰在线视频这里是全国 z影院 视频 15Ppapapa视频 啪啪影院软件 365福利影视 做爱视频教师 淫乳黄片 真实操的视频在线观看 国产自拍在线论坛 农夫AV神马枪AV神马影院 淫乱丝袜 国产性爱录音 欧卅自拍丝袜bt 欲噜啦 免费日本黄页视频100种 色狗中文综合网视 亚洲私房色 澳门皇家赌场 magnet 怡春院怡红美国十次综合 成年轻人床上视频网站 综合视频 偷拍自拍 国产自慰夜色 北京 小悠电话系列 草 波多野结衣一本道DVD 被老头揉搓奶头抽插视频 操我的嫩学生小骚货 Se678 爱色影mv 豆腐西施 av在线观看 susu85网站改成什么了 pppd-408链接 现实吉娜 成人3d 香蕉网婷婷 八戒TV网络电影 www,a片, 天使在线 null SSNI-241播放 蓝沢润 av在线 兰泽润电影全集 东方在线x最新网址 迅雷网盘AV资源 男人电影天堂丶 sifangpian 备用 WNZS-195 saozixaoshuo 超硪碰视频成人福利 操逼福利网站 鲍康捷 susu92成人 插极品美女小骚逼视频 超碰视频re 彩乃奈奈AV在线看 正在播放操逼的食品 jjzzz日本性爱黄色 铃木里美在线ck观看 欧美av种子磁力 下载 磁力链 下载女人与马 宅男av影院 丝袜会所享受长裙黑丝按摩毒龙口暴小姐 asia_fox 2016上海车模视频下载 激情影院嗯啊嗯啊嗯啊 添奶抽插视频 成都磁力链接 成人免费无码手机视频 亚洲一页 无码嘿嘿嘿种子 国货自拍 叉叉叉视频20p 操逼xxoo视频 韩国女主播福利导航 a∨在线观看进入 视频 xo小视频百度云 摩伊做爱视频 午夜福利707 好屌AⅤ视频4san,com 九哥操逼电影 教师丝袜美腿诱惑视频 日本eeeex 苍井空在线教师2015 国产深喉调教在线 阿v天堂2018v80 天无日天天射久草 色尼姑在线迷你 奇妙的美发沙龙 ftp 玩小姐过程视频娇喘 免费成人做爱在线视频 啪啪啪tossgirl 色嫂影院 美女叉叉叉动态图 毛色性一级片 裸体露乳视频 色丁香视频 轮奸里番 激烈床戏无遮挡视频 打电话 赤鸡 正在播放 yiseziyuanzan 菲菲去网站 玖玖操四虎视频 真人操逼视频免费 ipz-576在线播放 换妻书 快看午夜福利 亚洲第一成人综合视频 小红帽网站最新链接 抖音爱露露17分钟完整视频 kdh242com free 萝莉poen 美媛馆-mygirl写真官网 日在夏天 萆比克在线视频发布 爱丝视频 网络主播魅心户外帐篷 女神主播走光闪现视频在线 后入翘屁丝袜少妇小说 欧美变态深喉囗交 黄鳝视频21分钟完整版在线观看 狠射干人人操 花穴肉棒揉胸抓乳操视频 25se香蕉senv 男按摩师三级在线播放 一木道无码免费dvd 日本少妇毛片基地 亚洲在线偷 老鸭窝a片毛片免费观看 大陆自拍大全 爆乳在线 国产自拍视频在线动漫 刘小芸是三胞胎姐妹吗 拳交番号大全 国产自拍第66页 伦理片变态另类 亚洲图区淫妻乱伦 亚欧,日韩,中文在线 127 久鬼色色 1v1一本道大香蕉 wwwsao69 黑丝美女美腿诱惑视频 善国产自拍 大奶色图视频 新sss香蕉 国产在线2224 女烈专区 国外成人视频在线观看 好吊色妞在线视频播放 国语女主播野外直播 午夜性涩影院 红杏出墙韩国漫画百度云资源 下载 女人B脱毛视频 中年露脸自拍 花和尚福利导行 欧美无码AVmp4 韩国夏娃 ftp a片免费欣赏 人人干学生操 人人影视 GVG-541 thunder 神马电影网smd5 狂撸美女动图 国外男女裸露下体视频 动漫黄片10000部免费视频 聊斋之淫荡狐仙 日本女人的性生活和下水道囧图黄 凌虐乱伦小说 山边人体艺术 WWW_OMDY8_COM 色詀 日本性女学家人体模型 ac8a50ee0002f1b4 泽玛利亚大战黑人 欧美美女大炮15p图 打屁股2升级版 操老师影视查询 人与兽操逼网 WWW_BBS52PK_COM 肥胖女人裸体艺术 1毛片级 桑拿操逼李宗瑞 强奸少女的过程故事 欧美性爱360大奶网 人体艺术首页 亚洲色四房 有木有做爱的小说 狠狠干丰满女儿 撸女热 影音先锋全色网 小姨妈粉红嫩肉的 美女老师全裸体视频 男人鸡巴插入美女逼的图片